Long Island Bagel Cafe

"This review is to specifically shout out a certain employee named Andrea , she deserves 100 stars if it were possible. She treats every customer with care and concern, takes pride in her job, and always has a smile on her face. She has all the tools to be very successful in life . Shout out to Andrea!"

"I would leave zero stars… A wrap that is nearly the diameter of a quarter… would never waste my money here again. Absurd"

"I can't say enough about this place. I've been going here for years. ALL of their food is FANTASTIC and they always listen and accommodate when it comes to special instructions (I'm a weirdo who always orders the same salad and always asks for the dressing and the tuna on the side). I can definitely say they'll keep steadily getting my business! If you haven't tried their tuna salad and chicken salad, it's addictive! Thank you guys for always making my lunch something to look forward to."

"Excellent bagel and prepared food deli. Wide variety of large and fresh bagels. And, the prepared foods are fresh. Staff is friendly and hard working. Often a considerable line for service but the line usually moves quickly since they have sufficient staff helping. Prices are fair and comparable to other local bagel stores. Check local flyers for discount coupons. But, while bagel quality is similar to Bagel Boss, Bagel Boss has a slight edge in one area…they carry lox, herring and whitefish and LI Bagel Cafe only has lox. So, if you are looking for traditional Jewish or German-style bagel-related foods, there are a few gaps here. Still, if that doesn’t matter to you, this is an EXCELLENT bagel store with very nice prepared foods! HIGHLY recommended!"

"This place smells so good and is so clean I had a hard time picking something to eat. Went with a recent favorite I tried in the Baldwin location but with an egg everything bagel. Staff was super nice but I asked for black pepper and I think I got bell peppers instead. Didn't enjoy biting into bell peppers every bite but the sandwich itself was very tasty. The macaroni was sweeter than expected but I'll definitely be going back to try something else"