Brooklyn Bagel Boys / Coney Island Bagels 2829 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11235

"I decided to write a review hoping that the owners of these businesses will see my note and will think about it. Usually I buy bagels, tuna, cream cheese (different) from them. A few times I added a few croissants.The guys give a good service and I always tip them. I don’t say anything about the prices. I never pay attention. The bagels are good, tasty. But they need to be cooked a little longer, to make them a little bit well done. And I THINK THEY ARE TOO BIG. IT’S NOT A ITALIAN ROUND BREAD, IT’s A BAGEL. You will make more money if you make them 35-40% less by their size. Drop the price for 25% and make them smaller. Check the size of the bagels at Costco or BJs, make it that size and put your quality in it. You’ll get the best bagels in Brooklyn. I hope I was clear. P.S. I always ask for well done bagels that’s why they look good on my picture. The inside part goes into garbage."

"Nice bagel spot that serves up a pretty decent breakfast. Last time I was here I got the Greek omelet. The overall taste was pretty good. The cheese was extra tasty but I think the tomatoes watered the eggs down a little too much. My biggest complaint was that they forgot my toast, bit not a huge deal in the end if the day. I'll be back for sure to try some of those fresh bagles."

"Go see my guy bobby and ask him to make his special bagel. That place is amazing. The variety of cream cheese i mean they got it all freshest bagels in brooklyn !!! Freshest Bagels ever..."

"They have Tofu cream cheese!!! It was absolutely delicious. The place is clean. They have about four tables to sit and eat. Most people take their food to go. I sat on a Sunday morning and enjoyed my food and coffee. I had a toasted sesame bagel with lox, capers, tofu cream cheese and red onions! Delicious! Definitely my new Sunday Breakfast go to."

"They know how to make their bagels! These boys are FAT and perfectly soft. I ordered my meal through Uber eats and there was a promo for an extra 3 bagels which I had the next few days. They remained soft and chewy when retoasted which is amazing! My bagel sandwich with bacon egg and cheese was really filling. The omelettes could use some more work though, a bit under seasoned but still ok. Otherwise everything was great! Totally recommend getting a bagel here!!"