Grimaldi's Pizzeria Garden City

"The pizza was fair at best, and that's being generous. It was here a year ago and I recall it being very good, but no more. I guess things change. The 4% surcharge for using a credit card is outrageous."

"I haven't had pizza for about 3 weeks and I fell for it so bad, I was so excited to get pizza on Sunday from Grimaldi. I have ordered Joe Margarita pies one of them with topping and it was such a disappointment the bottom of the pizza was SO BURNT as you can see in the picture. I've been making pizza for the last 45 years so I can tell you I know what I'm talking about so disappointed disgusting tastes like burnt pizza. I can definitely tell you why the bottom was burned because they haven't used the oven for a while and they needed it to cool it down before you put a pie in it to cook."

"My favorite Grimaldi location. Super quiet neighborhood with a huge private parking lot. The service here is just perfect. I gotta be honest, this was so close to a 5 star review except the crust could have been cooked about a minute longer. Good undercarriage but could have been great. Don’t worry, I’ll still be back soon because it’s simply that good."

"While I have had a lot of pizza in my day, I can safely say that this place will… not blow you away. This review will not be as long as my others because there isn’t a whole lot to say. The atmosphere is nice nothing all that spectacular it’s pretty simple in its decor. The service is pretty average not to fast or to slow. The main issue with this restaurant is its food. I had ordered a vodka personal pie with meatballs. It is quite unfortunate that the sauce was incredibly bland. While the pizza had a nice char on the bottom and the cheese was well melted it is hard to say pizza is good with such a weak sauce. The second weight on the establishment is it’s price. Local pizzerias with full sized family pies even with toppings are still far cheaper. Therefore for half decent overpriced pizza I can recommend for a quick bite, but if your looking for the best pizza this place isn’t it."

"Pepperoni pizza was delicious and the crust is probably the best I’ve ever had! Buffalo chicken pizza was pretty average. Service was very poor. Our waiter visited our table maybe 3 times. The music in the restaurant was not fitting to the atmosphere and everyone in my party noticed which was pretty funny. We got 2 large pizzas for 5 guys and weren’t full by the end ($14 a person) and Just because of the service and experience I wouldn’t dine in again. Take out maybe"