Maestro's 1329 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10804

"Ordered a full order of scungili with pasta. I received someone’s leftover with other food in it (see below). Spoke with the owner- said he made it himself. Never patronizing this restaurant again."

"Good service, few tables but cozy, and the main tasty food."

"Went out to dinner last night with a friend and we decided to stop at this Gem! Maestro's is always consistent when it comes to whipping up the Italian classics and the staff is welcoming and kind. We ordered the Mozzarella Spedini and Calamari Arrabiata to start. My favorite appetizers on the menu! For the main course I asked our waiter Anthony to whip me up something different. I wasn't in the mood for pasta, but I wanted their Vodka Sauce. He mentioned to me their special of Veal Chop Parm, but he substituted the Marinara for Vodka Sauce and I instantly jumped on that. The plate arrived with this Tomahawk style Veal Chop oozing with Vodka Sauce! It was something I've never seen done before but I was all for it. The veal was very tender and full of flavor from the breading that it had. I will definitely make sure to order this again the next time I come here!"

"We’ve had their food a couple times and both times everything was cooked perfect and tasted good. Their menu has a lot of common Italian dishes so you’re used to a certain way of making certain things when it comes to that type of food and they didn’t disappoint. We felt their quality was a little better than other area restaurants but we usually use them more for an on the go type of meal."

"We’ve been here several times. Food is good, big servings, nice salad comes with meal. However, tonight was horrible. We asked the waitress if there was meat in a pasta dish and she said no. The person ordering keeps kosher and does not eat meat outside of her home. When she got her meal, she immediately tasted meat. We asked someone else if there was meat and he said yes. So instead of waiting for another dish to be cooked, we asked them to split a huge pasta dish one of us had. They charge $5 for sharing and said it was a rule and the manager wouldn't waive the $5 sharing charge even though it was their mistake!! The manager didn’t even come out to apologize. Terrible mistake. Should not have been charged!"