Milk N Cookies - Cookie Café & Cereal Bar

"Went there for the first time and first of all the smells when you open the door tells you how good the cookies are going to be, second the guy who was there was very nice and friendly making it two out of two. The I order five different types of cookies and all of them were very good. The oatmeal with apple was delicious and very interesting the Reases with peanut butter which I thought I was not going to like wind up been probably the best. Bottom line will go back again and again."

"I’ve been their customer and spent few hundred dollars since they just opened. On a recent visit the owner didn’t understand my orders and took a long time to make corrections, which is fine as mistakes can happen. But he turned pretty rude in the end, when I wasn’t angry or anything. Probably not going to go back anymore. Their cookies and ice creams are good, but not worthy enough to go regardless of the bad attitude I’ve unfairly received."

"Kudos on the creative aspect...great concept. We had the plain chocolate chip and trip chocolate...they were good...but not great. I prefer the consistency of Crumbl a bit better. The stuffed cookies may have a better consistency. I'll be sure to try one of those next time. We also had a vanilla cone which was about $7 regardless of the amount of topping you add...or none at all. We decided to get a plain cone...and didn't sit well to pay $7 for a plain cone. But the concept of having unlimited topping for a set price may be appeaking to some...especially those who like to load up on toppings. On a good note, the soft serve vanilla was very good. Large open and clean space with a few barstools and counter along the sides. Metered parking along Mamaroneck Avenue."

"Fun flavors, nice staff, delicious cookies, and in a bustling location. My friend and I really enjoyed our desserts from here."

"Fantastic cookie recipe, perfect on the sugar quantity, size and filled precisely. Its not overwhelming its perfect, tasteful! Second time visiting, the first time was blown away with quality, taste, service, hygiene, decor, everything in this location was well thought of. This time tried the Cookie Monster (got lucky it was the last one) and Cookies & Cream. Cookies are about $5 each and worth every bite! This is not a typical cookie, I consider them a gourmet cookie spot! The taste is definitely cookie, moist, not soggy or cakie. I WANT THE RECIPE - to show off of course, GREAT JOB!"