Goodfellas Pizzeria Inc 745 West Market Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301

"$20! Didn't fit in the box! Weighed 5 pounds! I can't stop eating. Best pizza in the Falls!"

"When you go here, make sure you ask how big the pizza is because a medium could have been shared between 3 people. They didn't really let use know that and we ended up with way too much pizza since we assumed it would be a good size for 1 person. Food was ok but could have had better service."

"Will never give this pizzeria my business again. Called for a delivery and was told an hour. An hour and 45 minutes later I still didn't have my order. When I called to cancel because I felt that wait time was unreasonable, their staff said whatever and hung up on me. I wasn't rude to them on the phone to illicit that response. I simply said I didn't want the order any longer because of the wait. I get the manager on the line after that and she doesn't like that I won't accept the order for a discount and she also hangs up on me. Never been treated with such disregard before by any business I've ever dealt with."

"Was hesitant after reading some reviews but overall the food was excellent. Ordered the half tray & wing special. The pizza & wings were excellent."

"If ever in Niagara Falls a definite stop for great pizza, wings, and salads is this place! The food was really great and freshly made. Because we had a large group we ordered 2 pizzas. First was the classic pepperoni pizza which was super cheesy. Second was with everything in it, and that was great. Both were large pans which have 15 slices each. We also ordered 50 wings, Parmesan/garlic, hot, and mild wings. Of course we tried the antipasto salad which was also really good. Finally an order of dessert bread that was really good. And with all of this food there was plenty to take home. Next visit to Niagara, a definite stop. $$$"