Colony Seafood And Steakhouse 876 Main Road, Irving, NY 14081

"Please don’t tell anyone about this place Best kept secret around Western NY area & possibly the best pasta sauce on the East Coast including New York City. & Toronto. With Lobster @ Yellow Pike plus Prime Rib to die for. Great service & charming Atmosphere & not too badly priced for what you get."

"Be careful when you order seafood from this place. I ordered the shrimp scampi from here and the poop lines were still intact in all of them you can see if you zoom in on the picture I took of it for yourself. I ate a shrimp the poop line still intact not knowing it was because I trusted this place but then realized it lost my appetite then told the waiter about it and she made pay for a different meal to switch out for that after taking away the shrimp scampi. Then comes over later and says that the reason why they still were intact was because they had a lot of seafood that day to deal with and some slip by like that. I won’t be returning back here after this I feel that they totally mishandled this situation and I feel bad for the employees that work at this place if they actually make their workers remove the poop lines in the shrimps when they could just buy already cleaned ones instead."

"The seafood there is amazing. The service is very detailed to the customer. Serving sizes are large . The crab stuffed shrimp was so delicious. And my spouse had the crab stuffed walleye. Very tasteful food, Our server Cheryl was very attentive and welcoming.."

"A great place to eat great food, relax and have a drink. We had the Haddock fish fry, a lot of food, too much to eat at one sitting. We should have shared. Service, Cheryl, was wonderful and attentive. Well decorated and music was low so we could chat. Clean and neat throughout the restaurant. Fish fry was $19.00, with an apperterizer a coke and a beer with tip for 2 was $79.00. Well worth everything! Stop in, you will be more than pleased and full."

"We had a great meal at Colony Seafood and Steakhouse. Each of us ordered a different menu item and we all enjoyed our meals. The portion sizes were plentiful and if it wasn't so good, it may have been enough to serve two people. The staff was attentive and friendly."