The Eis House,

144 Academy St, Mexico, NY 13114, United States

"Poor service. Our waitress didn't refill our drinks or even return to the table to check on us. We had to request the check in order to leave (which she refused to separate which made things awkward at our table). Terrible food. We waited a very long time for pasta that was cold and hard when it arrived. The tomato sauce was undoubtedly from a jar. Prices were high and selection was low. Disappointed in new owners. Quite obvious they are more concerned with having a party rather than serving dinners. Sadly, it's not what it used to be."

"Probably will NEVER eat there again seafood was horrible only get a few pieces of each. Brussel sprouts were burnt and cold. Waitress did not come to the table at all until we asked for our bill. I am usually a very good tipper we only left a 10% tip. They don't do separate checks so we had to add up all our own stuff to pay separately. Again won't go there again!!!! Not a big selection of food either!! Very very disappointed"

"Holiday party was incredible here. For Gin lovers they have Hendricks/Bombay. They have a wealth of great other alcohol selections. Bartenders were very nice and locals appears to like this bar. I really have nothing negative to say others it is off the beaten path in Mexico. Move this placee to Syracuse and ir would a license to print money"

"I’ve gone to the Eis House a few times in 2023 now, for events. We always try to get there early to enjoy the food. They serve a limited menu to the events, but it’s still so delicious. The place is always absolutely packed for these shows but they still get it done. We were quoted 1hr-1.5hr wait for the food and they had it out in just about an hour. It was hot and delicious. You do have to walk to the main bar for some drinks, but they do have a limited mini bar in the event room. Always impressive how this little venue handles such an enormous volume of guests for these shows!"

"A great friend and I ate dinner at Elis House last night and it was fantastic ! The roast beef special was more tender and delicious than any steak I've had in a long time. So good Chef James. The restaurant was so beautiful inside and while we noticed in one of their adds it looked like they only hosted large groups and weddings, they serve dinner for one or two or many! The staff was wonderful and very friendly and informative about the old ice house that was once there. What a great dining experience we had and we definitely will be back again soon."