New York Pizzeria

"Best pizza and wings within 100 miles full stop. Pizza is very close to actual NY city Pizza, wings are on par with places in Buffalo. Prices are amazing, we eat here once a week at least."

"Seriously best pizza and everything else!! I’ve never had bad food from the pizza shop I’ve been a loyal customer for 30 years, the owners are great too they do so much for the community! We are truly blessed to have this establishment in our town take the drive and check it out. Caution though the word has gotten out so call ahead for pickup orders there’s usually a long wait during dinner hours"

"I don't think the locals appreciate how good they got it! For someone from the Midwest, this is a hidden treasure, Just great, classic New York style pizzeria pizza, with a fantastic authentic small town atmosphere and service. The wings are also a great add-on to complete the experience. It's seriously in the middle of no where, but it you're close it's worth a visit."

"I hosted a Mickey Mouse party for my son's first birthday and asked the owner if they could put the pepperoni in the shape of Mickey.. I offered to buy the little pepperoni and bring it to them ahead of time but she assured me that wasn't necessary. I also requested they cut the large pizzas in 16 slices rather than the typical 8, and they were more than willing to accommodate! They went above and beyond! Great customer service, and great tasting pizza! Highly recommend!!"

"I'm a truck driver and here lately I've been picking up in Cato. Finally decided to try this place and to be honest they have some of the best wings I've ever had. The wings, Jenny style and charbroiled were just amazing. The pizza was made with fresh ingredients and just as amazing. The people working that night were real nice. Highly recommend and can't wait to get back there for the wings."