Carlo's

"Our daughter introduced us to Carlo's years ago and we have been loyal patrons ever since. I have NEVER had a bad meal! I am very fussy about my italian food and NEVER order meatballs out. Except for at Carlo's the one and only place I will eat a meatball outside of my kitchen. We are moving away and I truly wanted to get to Carlos one last time but I don't think it will happen. Thank you Carlo's for all the delicious meals and great family memories made at your restaurant."

"This is a review of the pizzeria not the restaurant,,yes they are same owner but separate kitchens and spaces. Our relationship is over with this establishment. I mean really,,I’ve been a customer since before they opened the pizzeria and your gonna sell me a day old slice that probably wasn’t refrigerated and not wrapped up properly but regardless any real pizzeria would NEVER even think of selling day old slices much less at the regular price AND charged me for the side of sauce as well to boot. For the record I did ask the individual who was attending the counter if she could do me the courtesy of selling me the Detroit style slice for 5$ because I was in the night before(when I asked they said “probably “ were)and the same two ricotta topped Detroit slices were at the display area again today at lunch time and she just disappeared. But this is an accumulation of just lack of quality and consistency of their products going on multiple years now. From selling regular slices for 4 plus$ that should be sold at dollar slice shop and I haven’t ordered other food products they sell for quite sometime due to the same reasons. The Detroit slices brought me back but now with this experience we are done and I want to inform everyone about this so you don’t waste your time and hard earned money on a product that has no care or consideration for that fact. But yet still advertises the fact of a superior product but the actual fact is it’s barely mediocre. I do not like doing this sort of thing but something has to change or think about finding a place with a better handle on their quality control. A good alternative and they are close by is Gino’s on Pondfield or Full Moon(best knots in town)on Palmer road across from Lawrence hospital. Thanks for all the years of great slices from the restaurant while trying to scrounge up money to buy an Lp from Rocking Rex,,yeah I go that far back,,,"

"An unpretentious old-school Italian ristorante serving generous portions of traditional favorites at very good prices. You can make three meals out of their veal (or chicken) sorrentino. But it's not just about portion size. It's about quality and taste. Carlo's has it all."

"This place has a pizzeria downstairs and a restaurant upstairs. I didn't have their pizza, I ate upstairs and was very happy with their food. Loved the penne ala vodka and the chicken parm. The staff was very friendly, and best of all, the food was very reasonably priced. I will definitely be going back."

"This place is top notch some of the best Italian food I’ve ever had!! Eat here! Hands down the best! Order the salad Italian dressing and don’t skip the bread - wow!!"