Attilio's Pizzeria

"Overpriced! I took a shot with this place and although the pizza is good, I just can't justify spending $11-12 for two slices of pizza and a soda! Now, I totally understand charging a little more for "specialty" slices, but seriously it's just pizza. And I know it costs next to nothing to make a pizza. I recently purchased a plain slice, a "specialty" slice, and a soda. The total came to $11 and change. Seriously? This place isn't exactly gourmet dining. I'll go a minute up the road next time and pay $2 a slice. It tastes just as good! IT'S JUST PIZZA!"

"Pizza was good but from a selfish perspective, I have to express dissatisfaction with the restaurant's logistics. I took my wheelchair-bound mother there for dinner. The entryway is difficult to navigate. All the chairs on the restaurant area are armless, and the bathroom is too tiny to allow a wheelchair in. I will not visit again but would be open to take-out."

"I recently visited Attilio's Pizzeria in Freehold, NJ, and overall, it was a decent experience. I ordered a meat lovers pizza to go, and while it wasn't the best pizza I've ever had, it was still tasty. The pizza had a generous amount of meat toppings, but the crust was a bit thicker and doughier than I prefer. However, what really stood out to me was the poor customer service. When I arrived, there weren't many customers inside the restaurant, yet the staff seemed disinterested and not very welcoming. When I called ahead to place my order, the person who answered the phone sounded uninterested and didn't seem to want to help me. As someone who values good customer service, this was disappointing. That being said, I do want to acknowledge that this was likely a one-off experience, as Attilio's Pizzeria is typically known for having good customer service. I would be willing to give them another chance in the future and hope that the service will be better. One aspect of Attilio's Pizzeria that I did appreciate was the convenience of getting the pizza to go. The process was quick and easy, which is always a plus. Overall, I would rate Attilio's Pizzeria 4 out of 5 stars. If the customer service had been better during my visit, it would have easily been a 5-star experience. Despite the poor service, the pizza was decent, and I would recommend giving it a try if you're in the area."

"Was really great the first time I went but the pizza was burnt the second time."

"I visited NJ then NY for a total of 3 days with an explicit goal to try as much pizza as I could. I started at Attilio's and was blown away at both the quantity and quality of pizza I could get for $5 (2 plain slices). I had a lot of great pizza on the east coast (not as good as Chicago deep dish, sorry) but the clear winner was Attilio's; best slice and best price."