Toasted

"We randomly went here on our walk home from the Airbnb. This place is totally something you would see in Seattle and/or Ithaca, I live right outside of there. I had no idea what to expect when we entered. There was a band playing with some interestingly looking patrons that could have all passed for 18. Not a bad experience, but it was definitely an odd experience. Considering I love both Seattle and Ithaca, that says a lot. Probably would have enjoyed it more if it was a different band and crowd."

"Love the atmosphere here. Experienced, knowledgeable bartenders and cooks. They put all their love into the drinks and food! Every time I’ve dined here, it’s been nothing but the best time. The owner Sam is lovely. Definitely created a great establishment that the community needed. Highly recommended!"

"Indoor and outdoor seating available. We went on a Friday night for a 90s 00s band @runforcoverNY The owner Sam was there making sure everyone had a good time. The bartenders were mixing up refreshing drinks with souvenir ducks floating on top. We only had a few apps but we'll definitely be back for a full meal. If you're in Newburgh, forget the river. Head over to Liberty Street and check out Toasted."

"Sam and the team at Toasted are amazing. I guarantee any time you walk into this place, you will be getting an excellent meal. The atmosphere is hip, and the backyard is the spot to be in Newburgh on a Friday or Saturday night. I can't wait for the summer to enjoy some more evenings at Toasted."

"The staff are so lovely and efficient, the food is super DELISH, and the cocktails are well-balanced. Brussel sprouts and butternut squash soup were exactly what I needed for a misty fall evening. Fried chicken sandwich with fries was perfect. Apple torte dessert was excellent. Highly recommend for lunch and dinner!"