Nothing New Thrift Shop

"Very unhappy with my experience here. I would not recommend going to this thrift store. The owner is very nasty and ungrateful. The staff is also extremely nasty. If I could give this store zero stars I would."

"I have been going to nothing new thrift shop for several years, from their first locations to their latest location. Through the years, I have always dealt with the owner Jodi, who is an absolute ANGEL. Her staff are all wonderful as well. Dina, Nella & Faith are simply AMAZING. They are friendly, personable, helpful, and accommodating. When you walk into nothing new thrift shop, you’re not just going there to buy secondhand, it’s like catching up with friends. You’re always greeted with a smile and they genuinely seem happy to see you. I will be a customer there for the rest of my life."

"I always have the best time when going to Nothing New to shop! Jodi and John are amazing and their staff Nella and Dina are just incredible and very friendly. When you walk into nothing new you will always find something new and incredible! There’s always something great to find! I would recommend Nothing New to Everyone! This is the best place to shop in Staten Island, better than department stores!"

"You name the item and odds are Jodi has it at her store. Mainly home decor ,pictures, books , candles , silverware /dishes etc. Even a spacious basement choc full of childrens toys and Christmas decor. Staff is super friendly. During my last venture , I scooped up these 3 candles. It’s not a expensive place either . There’s always a sale going on …Check it out— you won’t be disappointed"

"This is a great place to find tiny treasures or massive dressers. I always find something. It's also a great way to give a new life to gently used items. Some items we picked up for our granddaughter were a table lamp, a cupie doll, and Raggedy Ann and Andy wall mounts."