Goodwill NYNJ Store & Donation Center

"Prices used to be better when they first opened. Now it’s hit and miss sometimes you find something nice other times I walk out empty handed. Most times if there is something remotely nice or a brand that is good the prices are way to high . $30 for used shoes ? And $12 for Walmart pajamas used? They price each piece a minimum of 5.99 . Also why are you separating matching sets ? Like pajamas and suits . You have to dig and try to see if there is a match somewhere. Just put the sets together and then price accordingly. So annoying to find a nice mens suit jacket only to never find the pants . Also housewares is way overpriced . Though I like to still go and see what I can find I usually find something to buy and many things that also are way way overpriced."

"As a partially disabled woman who cares for both my disabled parents I find it disgraceful, deplorable, and disgusting behavior to not allow one of your disabled customers to use your restroom. The rudeness and insensitivity displayed by this stores staff is atrocious. "Ally's Law" aka "The Restroom Access Act" specifically prohibits retail establishments from denying customers with medical conditions access to their bathroom facilities. This store, and it's staff, have not only violated the law, they've also violated that poor woman's human rights, and have made a mockery of the very ideology of what your organization supposedly stands for. I guess it's a good thing "Charity begins at home" because it certainly doesn't exist in the hearts of your employees or their manager. Shame on all of you."

"I LOVE THIS GOODWILL STORE! This year our family has decided to have a themed “Thriftmas Exchange!” - the rule is only thrift store gifts. I stop at this particular store every week on my way to the city and it never disappoints. Needless to say, my Thriftmas list is complete and I’m still finding wonderful gifts for birthdays, anniversaries, etc. This store is very busy, well organized, clean & the young staff is extremely polite. I met the manager, and he was genuinely grateful for my compliments. Continued success Middletown Goodwill. EXCELLENT STORE ♥️"

"Nice clean store but to charge $5.99 for a Walmart brand boundaries tank top? The draw for Thrift store is nice stuff gently used but if I can buy this new at Walmart on clearance... hmm. Other items looked very clean prices ok. Just very low quality thrifting here."