Brooklyn Square Pizza 73 Wilson Avenue, Manalapan Township, NJ 07726

"Brooklyn Square Pizza was fantastic; the food was great and the service was wonderful! We were a large group and I walked in first with my kids, we were instantly greeted and a table was ready for us. Every server was friendly and made us feel welcomed. (She even laughed at my corny mom jokes.) The food was delicious, even my kids gobbled their food up and mine! The one server even asked me for permission to give all the kids a little lollipop which was not only generous but thoughtful to ask first. The vibe was very relaxed yet the service was up scale. If I didn’t live so far away, I’d definitely go back. Highly recommend it!"

"I am not a pizza person but this pizza was just… I have no words. It melted in my mouth. We brought the rest home and it tasted the same for next 2 days!"

"Amazing pizza! Personally loved thin pizza compared to Brooklyn style thick ones but definitely different kick to regular Italian pizza"

"Excellent place. Seems unfairly under advertised, or perhaps I've never heard of it, but that's now changed. Service was excellent. Very polite, friendly, attentive. Food was delicious. Authentic pizza, great pasta and awesome salad. Definitely hit the spot, so much so we're still talking about it the next day."

"1st time ordering the upside down pizza and it was just okay. 2nd time I ordered, I tried jersey Square and it taste so much better even though it seemed like the same pizza except for pepperoni being on it. It also tasted like it had some sweet spots as if the sauce had sugar in it but only on certain parts. This is a pizza that I would eat when I'm in the area but not travel for it."