Milltown Diner 30 North Main Street, Milltown, NJ 08850

"ordered an omelet it was burnt and dry. I had better eggs while in the army and they came straight from a bag. I also ordered French toast that literally came with 24 micro dots of powdered sugar. I'm far from a food critic in a world where everyone with a car and camera is a food critic now. Had high hopes but we fell short."

"Milltown Diner is an exceptional old school diner. We stopped in for breakfast and were greeted immediately. Everyone at the diner was very friendly. The service was excellent as was the food. Everything was hot and fresh. The coffee was quite good. Everything tasted homemade. I recommend the corned beef hash. All the prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. Free limited parking on the street."

"I visited Mill Town Diner on a chilly December 12 afternoon at 1pm. Nestled in the heart of downtown, the diner was a cozy haven with convenient street parking nearby. The interior exuded a classic diner charm, clean and welcoming. I tried the 'Three Eggs Kielbasa with Potato Pancakes' and it was a delightful choice. The kielbasa was cooked to perfection, complementing the savory potato pancakes. The service here deserves a special mention - prompt and courteous, adding to the overall warmth of the diner. This place is an excellent pick for anyone looking for a comforting meal on a cold day, especially if you’re a fan of hearty breakfasts. Highly recommend for its delicious food and charming atmosphere!"

"Little hole in the wall. Reminded me of small diners from 70s & 80s. Generous portions, decent prices, coffee cup stayed full. If your not looking for ambiance, you will not be disappointed. Food was extremely tasty. I parked in a lot across the street. It didn’t say I couldn’t. It’s street parking which deducts the point for me."

"Decided to give this place a try based on some pretty good reviews plus it wasn’t that far away. Parking is available on street or directly across in a public parking lot, on a Sunday morning it was easy to park in the lot. It’s located in a house and when you enter the front door there’s 2 doors and the entrance to the diner is to the right. The place is dated, however, it was intimate with patriotic decorations along with many sports memorabilia, all in all, it had a family feeling. Based on the staff interactions with a few customers (regulars for sure) we enjoyed some of the banter that was going on, we even laughed a few times. Alright, let’s get to the food. Orange juice was ordered, but it had a metallic taste, notified our waitress and she immediately explained that it was the 2nd complaint and replaced it with apple juice. She stated that it was a new vendor and after our complaint they discarded the remaining containers of OJ. She even tried it and agreed it didn’t taste right. Now diners usually have those paper placemats that have all those advertisements, well they had their coffee cups designed with the ads, thought that was innovative. Had the eggs Benedict with corned beef hash and the belly buster. The eggs Benedict was delicious and a HUGE portion (3 eggs too) over English muffins with hash browns. The belly buster (another HUGE portion), I believe it was bacon, ham, sausage, cheese and potatoes, however I was disappointed that the potatoes were in the omelette. Basically, it appears they placed all the ingredients on the griddle and poured the 4 eggs directly on these ingredients. It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t a real omelette either as it wasn’t added over the eggs as a filling and folded over. I would have preferred the potatoes on the side as it detracted from the “omelette”. The amount of food was enough for 3 meals (each) and we took home the copious amount of food. A bonus, I have to add, asked for hot sauce and the waitress brought 2 different bottles, Cholula (my favorite) and a jalapeño and green chili sauce (didn’t try). We really enjoyed the atmosphere as it appeared to be a local and friendly place, wish I could give it 5 stars, but like I stated earlier, the belly buster just missed the mark. The service was outstanding and we will definitely come back for either lunch or breakfast again (so many options to choose from). Highly recommended."