Wholly Cow

"This is Rahway's ultimate hangout spot. The coffe is smooth and gelato is delicious. There are plenty of flavors to satisfy any sweet tooth. I've visited this lovely shop several times and the service is always friendly. The atmosphere is so welcoming. Whether you're on a date, hanging out with friends or need a place to settle down with your laptop, Wholly Cow Gelato is the spot with all the right vibes. Kid & dog friendly. Vegan options available."

"Went here last night with my girls and husband - omyyyygoodness! The gelato is divine!!! Pistachio is my fav flavor thus far :) We enjoyed it so much! Not only is it a cozy home like vibe but the owner is super sweet and makes you feel so welcomed. Despite my little girls running around and being loud/messy, she went above and beyond to give them a hot coco making experience (not on the menu)! I will def be going back and you all should too!! :)"

"I actually ran into this gem by mistake, walking home.. and I have no regrets. This ice cream is top tier, the formula and mix of batter is so flavorful and creamy.. I just want to indulge it forever ! The store is extremely clean, could literally lick the floor. Smells good, love the esthetic, owner is such a lovely and precious person .. she really made the experience ! Ordered the cookies and cream gelato and the banana dulce de leche (this one goes to my banana fiends, it’s definitely a banana lover type of ice cream). Ice cream sustained itself and didn’t melt, as other local creameries, consistency reminded me of cold stone tbh! It was BOMBBBBB! The only sad point I have to make is that they don’t have any lids to go in the (small) size, luckily I live a few blocks away so I was able to walk fast and make it ! Or else I would’ve rated it a 5-5 ! Hands down best place everrrr!"

"Took a stroll after the Mayor's summer concert to check out the new Gelato shop. Picked up a small with 2 flavors and was the perfect size to end the night. Espresso and coconut, a perfect combination."

"This spot is a nice addition to downtown Rahway! The gelato I had the pleasure of trying was delicious! The strawberry jam peanut butter cookie sandwich was divine. The place has a nice vibe and there is plenty of seating. Staff was friendly. I will be returning. Highly recommended!"