Temptations Cafe

"Used to love coming to temptations all these years but after the recent transfer of ownership the quality of food and especially service has gone down, I don’t typically leave reviews like these, but my experience tonight wasn’t great and solidified my feelings. Understandingly after a busy day with a street fair the staff may be tired, but the store was still open so the service should still be welcoming..I called to make sure they were open 30 minutes before closing and on the phone were already saying they were about to close..we arrive the man behind the counter is clearly overextended by the end of the day and the service didn’t go very well he was short and overall unwelcoming. Got some ice cream to go and the Reese’s topping was very stale. Just the service and quality has gone down. Felt it warranted a review unfortunately."

"Wow, came here on a recommendation. Didn’t look like much outside and inside I thought they only had ice cream. But then I sat in the cozy back area and had the best salad I’ve had since was in Italy."

"Good service (and fast!) I've been going here since I was a very little girl. I now go there to enjoy their pesto pasta and some sangria. It's not the CHEAPEST place to eat but it's reasonable and they have very good quality food. To those complaining about pricing, good luck finding a cheap restaurant on main Street that isn't Chinese food. To those complaining about service or servers, the person who served you is most likely gone and I'd give the place another try"

"After walking the town, what a nice way to enjoy lunch, sitting at the window table of Temptations Café, doing some lazy people watching. A local recommended this place as a favorite. We agree. Very unassuming décor, nice menu – food was remarkably good. We shared a Pastrami Reuben and an order of Kobe Beef Hot Dogs with thick cut bacon and a delicious sweet BBQ dressing on a tasty toasted bun. Kobe or not, the hot dogs were certainly the best or a tie for the best “dog” ever. Service was very attentive. Nyack is a lovely town. We walked Main St and Broadway – filled with people and their pets out enjoying the first real sunny weekend of the season."

"Great little place on main street with awesome food and atmosphere. Layed back and easy going. Fantastic menu, accomodating wait staff. Nice people."