Valley Pizza 4 Lakeridge Drive, Valley Cottage, NY 10989

"Very good Italian and pizza. Always on time with your pick up order not like the competition!"

"If you haven't eaten here yet you are definitely missing out, chef Tom's food is absolutely incredible, and I'm not just talking about one thing it's everything ask about his sliders and definitely try the pizza. The eggplant parmesan is to die for."

"This was my first time getting pizza from this location. We came to NewYork for a wedding and came in late last night and needed to try New York style pizza. I got a cheese pizza with sausage, mushroom and onions. The pizza came to our hotel room within 45min and it was through Grubhub. The food was good and pizza looked great. The cheese as delicious and the toppings were amazing. I should’ve gotten more/Extra sauce on. Overall it was great!"

"Valley pizza is horrible! Do not waste your money. The food is disgusting and so is the service. I ordered a simple pie and garlic knots. The pizza was a mess and the garlic knots were burnt and hard as a rock. When I called to complain the owner wouldn’t even get on the phone with me. Instead, he could be heard in the background yelling “there’s nothing I can do about”. Good thing I can do something about it! I’m never going back and neither should you. I wish I could give them zero stars."

"I’d give no stars but then I cannot post my review!!! I have ordered from this place so many times, and have never been disappointed. However, according to the description on the menu the BLT wrap is “overstuffed” with bacon. Clearly there is no bacon as you can see in the pictures. Then when I call to inquire I am told by the manager who was rude and condescending "well you ordered it without tomato, so clearly it's not stuffed". Then he tells me about the pork shortage, so instead of explaining to customers that the meals may be a bit skimpy they send 2 strips of bacon and lettuce in a wrap for $8.50! And then have the nerve to be angry as to why I’m inquiring, and talk to me in a derogatory manner!! Never again!!"