West Nyack Pizzarena,

726 W Nyack Rd, West Nyack, NY 10994, United States

"Whether I have delivery or I pick up my order lately I have issues with my order. I ordered a grilled chicken Caesar Wrap & a thin crust Sicilian pie tonight - I was advised it would be $34 and would be delivered in 30 minutes - delivery took well over an hour and instead of a thin crust Sicilian pie we recieved a regular pie - when I called to complain I spoke with the manager Nick who claimed we were only charged for a regular pie not the thin crust Sicilian - based on the prices online I was definitely overcharged At this point I think I am done - how many times can you screw up a simple order? There are other restaurants that I can go to - they just don't seem to care and they definitely overcharged me & claimed they didn't- sorry to say I will no longer be patronizing your business"

"Great first time pizza! Thick crunchy crust covered with plenty of cheese and sauce. Gave me the pie directly from the oven as a walk-in customer. Will return for sure and deal with the lack of parking space."

"I had walked in about a hr before closing. The pizza was delicious. I ordered one slice of chicken back ranch and margarita. My uncle order 2 slices of reg. The quality of the sauce and the counter service was 10/10 welcome environment & love that they have all the seating. I am visiting from Florida and will be back."

"the pizza here is very good the fried calamari comes with tentacles but we only had two on the whole dish it was very strange when I took a slice of the pizza all the cheese slipped right off. they definitely don't skimp on the tomato sauce our server was really sweet and helped us even though they had no table service that night."