Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria

"Okay I hate to do this but this is the second time I've gotten pizza here. I just wanted a plain pie. I like my pizza a little bit thick but I get they don't cook it that way here from what it looks like. That's not why I gave a bad review. This pizza was waaaaaay overcooked. All you could pretty much taste is burnt trust. This is the second time this happened. Overall the regular Italian food is good here but I won't get pizza here again. No match for lunello's though If you're going to pay those kind of prices."

"So much better than the Barstool review on Youtube tells you. My brother and I had a late lunch there recently. Walking in, you automatically feel this is an older (more like "classic") spot, with the older, used pizza ovens. Service was excellent, with our server and various other employees checkin in on us periodically, but not so frequently that we were harassed. Starting with the amuse, bread and butter may seem simple, but when you've got good cripsy outside, fluffy inside Jersey Italian bread, you can't have a better start. Clams casino had HUGE chunks of bacon (always a win), the wings were nicely crispy even though smothered in sauce, and brussels sprouts are good enough a vegetable hating fella would fall in love with them, Full disclosure, we didn't get the original cheese that the barstool guy had, we went with the Thinny Thin, and it was glorious. Crispy all the way through, zero flop, a satisfying medium crisp with ever bite. Very tasty crust, just the right amount of cheese so the slice wasn't greasy and the sauce had a nice flavor that made you want more even when finished. As a former Jersey guy/now Brooklyn resident, this pizza can stand with some of the best I've had in BK. Looking forward to the next time I visit my brother so we can try some of the other apps and pizzas."

"They initially sat us down in the darkest unlit side of a empty dining hall - when we tried to move to a different table the waitress wouldn’t let us for some odd reason. The tables were sticky and smelled like damp rotten towels A dead fly randomly fell and landed on our table. Ordered the “thinny thin” - it was very dry and hard to chew. Inedible overcooked pizza. Overpriced for a very thin pizza Our caprese salad for TWO could’ve used some more arugula - overpriced for what we got Buffalo wings were just “ok” Expected so much more."

"The famous thinny thin pizza is definitely worth the trip. Good crunch, the burnt Parmesan cheese on the crust was a great finish to a great pie. I recommend getting a whole pie. I Grabbed a slice of pepperoni and the roni was good but the pizza itself was better fresh out the oven. Next time I'm doing 1/2 roni."