Pie Guys Pizza Inc. 775 Hamburg Turnpike, Wayne, NJ 07470

"Had Pie Guys for the first time today and I can hands down say it is the best pizza place in Wayne. I’ve been working in Wayne for a year now and have tried all the other joints around my office and they’ve all let me down. Pie Guys didn’t. My only regret is not trying here sooner. The pizza was cooked to perfection and was thin and crispy. The sauce was incredible- not too sweet, not too salty. They couldn’t have done it better. I’m done trying new places - Pie Guys has earned my loyalty after just this one visit."

"I ordered ziti with Alfredo sauce and there was like 40 noodles in the container with barely no sauce. I literally saw the bottom of the container when I opened it. For the price you are charging and the cost of pasta you can definitely fill the container. I always used to order but no more. Not worth it. Very disappointed"

"Pie Guys has the best pizza in North Jersey, hands down!! Their grandma pie, Buffalo chicken, fifth grader, chicken cheesesteak pizza are all fantastic! Kevin always treats all of his customers with respect and kindness, all while making the pizzas himself! I’ve personally seen him make my pies and would not want anyone to make them for me now. I’ve dined in, ordered takeout, and delivery, and all options were timely and I was always pleasantly surprised! Give Pie Guys a try if you want to eat the best pizza in New Jersey!!"

"TL;DR: Congratulations Kevin, you lost a few families worth of customers but I wish you all the best. It really pains me to write this but this place just isn't the spot for a good pie anymore. I ordered a couple pizzas with my family for lunch. We ordered a regular size traditional pie and a personal Hawaiian pie for myself. The order took about 1.5 hours to get here and when we opened the boxes we could tell the pizza was cold. Not a huge deal for me personally -- I can put it in the oven for a couple minutes. But I couldn't help but notice something looked off with my pizza but I continued to re-heat it. As I started eating I quickly realized there was literally no tomato sauce on the pizza. It was a thin layer of dough, barely any cheese, with some ham and pineapple. The only sauce on the pizza was a drizzle of hot sauce I had requested. I've included a couple photos to show the pizza I received and how thin the slice is because there is literally nothing on it! No tomato sauce, barely any cheese... When we spoke to the manager 'Kevin' his attitude was incredibly defensive insisting that he had made the pizza himself and there was tomato sauce on the pizza. I told him I had no problem sending them a photo of the pizza I received as I was sure it was just a mistake but he kept insisting it wasn't necessary and there was tomato sauce admitting maybe it was a 'little light'. I was just calling to let you know you may have forgotten the sauce, dude. I wasn't angry, I wasn't yelling... I was just disappointed in the quality of the food I received. I wish I was making this up because this is seriously the place I would order from when friends came over and wanted a good slice of Jersey pizza -- but this just isn't it anymore. I can forgive a cold pizza, or a pizza without tomato sauce but as I am in the service industry as well what I can't forgive is Kevin's attitude and sheer lack of care when I told him the concerns with my order. Genuinely not ordering from here anymore..."

"Saving this on my list of Favorite pizza places! Thank you so much for the incredible Sicilian pizza. Haven't had pizza that good in years. The zeppoles were fabulous as well. Great service, even faster deliver! Shout out to Sal for the great service! Great smile you wear, All the customers should be very pleased."