Tony D's

"Walked in and was immediately greeted and served. Ordered a slice and a square. The pizza was good. Could use some more sauce. Also should have been warmed up a bit more. Overall 6/10."

"The. Best. Gluten. Free. Pizza. Let’s be honest, some gluten free pizza taste like chewy cardboard - Tony D’s taste like actual delicious pizza!! Do not overlook this gem. They are off the main road and hidden in a small shop but they know how to make a mean pie, fresh! Our favorite? The white pie!"

"The D in Tony D stands for delicious, we just moved back to the area and needed to find a gluten free pizza place as my oldest has a wheat and peanut allergy. Another reviewer called out that their gluten free was the best. I confidently agree, we've had gluten free pizza all over NJ it's hit and missed but this was the closest to fooling me into thinking it wasn't gluten free. My oldest, 6 yo, with the allergy would not stop asking for more, he would have finished the whole thing if you let him. He will usually have two slices(these are always personal pie sized) but he had over half the pie before we had to cut him off. Our little guy(2 yo) usually go for a normal slice but he was also aggressively eating the gluten free. We had no adverse reactions from the gluten free pizza The normal pizza was fantastic l, I am not sure if it's the best I've had but I can't think of anything that has been better in recent memory. I can't wait to go back."

"Tony D's never disappoints! First off - they have THE BEST gluten free pie we have found to date. I hosted a party and people without gluten allergies we're eating and raving about their gluten free pie! That's when you know it's good. Their square pies are great too- at least that is what my friend and family who eat gluten tell me. I definitely recommend Tony D's!"

"Tony D's is one of the celebrated pizzeria's in Caldwell. Tucked around the corner from the community pub Cloverleaf Tavern, you might be forgiven for missing it. Take away only, but they're bustling. Really cool pies too - they're doing the square sicilian-type pie. Drunken Grandma? Vodka sauce - yes please. Little Italy, with fresh crumbled sausage and long hots? Of course. Both pictured on this review. It's easy to see why this place is so loved among locals, and some of my friends drive 30 mins to pick it up."