Italian Villa,

445 Pinehurst Road, Plumsted, NJ 08514

"This place is a hidden gem. My wife and I got a scratch off date night book and said to go to a place we had never been. So we decided on Italian. I was overly impressed with every part of the experience we had. From the service, to the dimmed atmosphere. One of the cooks joked with us about the cheese cake because I told my wife not to look at it and of course he paraded it around and let her get a very good look at it. Needless to say we got a couple slices to go. The entrees were first rate! Probably the best fettuccine Alfredo I’ve had. Pasta cooked to perfection! My wife’s Gnocchi was amazing! I’m a little bit of a garlic bread snob being from eastern Connecticut, but was so impressed by the cheesy garlic bread! I can tell it wouldn’t matter the plate you’d get, it would be amazing. A must visit kinda place! Will be back sooner than later."

"We recently moved to the area and a friend told us you’ve got to have there pizza it’s the best you ever tasted. Will not only is the pizza the best so are the sandwiches and dinners. The people that work there are great as well. We love this place. And it’s BYOB"

"If I was on death row and had to pick my last meal, I'm ordering it from here. It's like they make their food out of the love my father never gave me. The worst thing you can get here still gets 5 stars. Don't miss this spot. It's just so good."

"Amazing food & staff. They have homemade pasta, very tasty. Portions are big and the atmosphere is perfect. If you want a good pasta dish is the place!! We will be back to try out the sandwiches"

"Do not drive by this unassuming spot! Came here for my dad's birthday and had a great time. Place is very cozy and our waitress was awesome, as was the rest of the wait staff and the owner. All of the food was great, really loved the stuffed meatballs and their homemade pasta! Really lovely experience and can not wait to come back again!"