Chocolate In the Oven Bake Shop 53 Bridge Street, Milford, NJ 08848

"We stopped by to see what they have and I got a Oreo cheesecake and it was fantastic we are going to have to go back and try the other items that they have they all look fantastic"

"Heaven on earth! So far I haven't had anything that is less than awesomely divine! Perfect choclatelyness, perfect sweetness and delightful flavors and textures in every treat I have tried (and have tried a few too many lol and no regrets). From chocolate things to citrus cakes- it's all too good! Thankfully I live a few towns away because if I lived closer I would weigh a lot more! Highly recommend all the delightful goodies sold here!"

"From the moment we pulled up to bakery we were excited! The decor was a great! We were greeted with smiles as soon as we walked through the door. We had the NYE buttercream cookies and they were amazing. The buttercream was so good. My boys are still talking about the cookies hours later and how nice they were decorated! We can’t wait to return and try more goodies."

"We have gotten multiple cakes, many cupcakes, cookies, pastries and everything has been delicious. My cannoli cake birthday cake was great, my husband loved his strawberry shortcake birthday cake. Pistachio eclairs are out of this world. The cutest themed sugar cookies for each holiday that taste as good as they look. M&m cupcakes are also a favorite. If there are any issues with anything, they will always make it right. We love this bakery, as do many others in the area, and we will always be back!"

"Amazing bakery with lots of amazing sweets! So much to looks at and choose from! From hot coco bombs to huge cakes and pies, to decorate your own cookie kits, they have it all! Huge selection of single baked goods, cupcakes, truffles, gingerbread cookies, biscotti, magic cookie bars, pecan bars and so much more. Wonderfully decorated for the season. Only reason I gave four stars was the price, one decorated sugar cookie was $4.50, way to much for just one cookie. Stop by tho if you're not on a budget, everything looked super yummy!"