DiCarlo’s Pizza - St. Clairsville

"DO NOT go by the hours posted here. I was in the area and went 30 minutes out my way to come here. I arrived at 1:00 to the sign on the door saying open but no lights on and no one inside. I tried to call and after a few rings someone picked up for a few seconds, said nothing and then hung up. Looks like this place is heading downhill based on other recent reviews. Be warned."

"The people and the food was absolutely amazing. We are from oit of town and work in the area and I will definitely be eating the pizza and salad here again and again. The pizza was excellent!!!!"

"Worst one of them all go to moundsville if you want good pizza this one up in town sucks trying to order the guy kept talking over me and that’s the manager. Got my pizza with no sauce just butter on the crust came no cheese, one piece pepperoni. And the other time you got piles of cheese, and I’ll kinds of pepperoni on it never again will I ever go to Di Carlos pizza in st.c"

"So, we are not from here and when we heard about Pittsburg style pizza, we were skeptical. I mean, who wants cold cheese on pizza? But we were pleasantly surprised. The crust and the sauce were really the superstars of this pizza. Crispy and chewy crust, delicious sauce. We ordered a full sheet and took it back to our hotel and by the time we got back, the cheese was a little melty, but honestly, we didnt hate it. The flavor of cheese is still there. We were surprised that toppings weren't really a thing. We got pepperoni and there were a few, but again, its not this style. If you like crust and sauce as the main part of pizza, this is for you. Give it a go!"

"Great little pizza shop. Service was great. I haven’t had the pizza in a long time. But man still taste the same. Best part is you can get it by the slice. But had to go with the 6 cut for me."