New Sheffield Cafe

"I did a large order through DoirDash. With a large tip. They sent me the wrong order. They put some chicken salad with a receipt with my name on the bag. It did not match the DoorDash receipt. I called the restaurant to please bring me the right order. The manager told me to keep reordering and repaying until they get it right … Seriously? It’s theft but it is what it is. Avoid take out at all costs from this establishment."

"First time here, get the Eggs. Shut up and order the Carrot Cake Pancake....got the #6 - 3 Eggs over easy, Hash Browns that were cooked perfectly ( No Onions or Peppers) just how I like them with a side of Hot Sausage. The Hot Sausage was split and pretty good. Then as always we ordered a side of Sausage Biscuits and Gravy to try. The Gravy was great and has a decent amount of Pepper, which I like. The Sausage in the Gravy was larger and sweeter than most of the places I've been, I prefer it chopped up and mixed in more, but if large chunks is your thing this is your place. Lastly the star of breakfast was the Carrot Cake Pancake. I don't even like Carrot Cake all that much, this was amazing.. Order it. Place is worth the trip. Oh and they have a Full Bar for the Bonus Points."

"Wait until you see the pics of their food! They have one of the best burgers in Beaver County! They are just the right thickness. Not too thick that it takes away from the joy of the flavors. The mushroom and Swiss with grilled onions is amazing! Then they have thes deep fried hot pepper rings! What? Yes they deep fry the hot pepper rings and oh so good! The fried fish sandwich can stand up to any from the local fish fries too! Definitely a place to have lunch or supper. And the next time I am getting one of their beautiful pieces if cake they have in the cooler as you enter the door. Our waitress was very attentive, everything was neat and clean. Plenty of seating in several areas."

"First time for early dinner. We had the Bret's Special and Gyro. Service overall was great. The salad was good not great. The beer was cold but no frosted mugs. According to my guest the Gyro was very good. My Bret's Special had three over cooked meats steak, chicken and shrimp. The rice pilaf was excellent. The bread was also excellent. The fries were very good. Overall the meal was good but not great. I would go back to try more of the menu. The menu is very diverse. The second visit we had fried shrimp and shrimp kabobs. The kabobs were good. The fried shrimp were not so great."

"Came here for the first time with my mom after they relocated from Aliquippa. Parking in the new location is not great, especially for those with mobility problems. But the building itself is really pleasant and relaxing to sit in. Was surprised how many people were there in the bar area-- clearly this place is popular! The dining area was a little less crowded. We were served very quickly. We split the fried zucchini and shrimp basket. Both were delicious! We were very happy eating here and would definitely come again."