Three Wishes,

1418 Beach Lake Highway, Beach Lake, PA 18405

"Our first experience at Three Wishes for our wedding rehearsal dinner in October 2019 was delightful. The delectable dishes and wonderful ambiance made it a memorable evening. However, today's visit was an absolute disappointment. The lack of flavor in my mom's white clams over penne pasta and my own shrimp and prosciutto aioli over penne was disheartening, and the dishes were oddly watered down. To make matters worse, I decided to order a to-go portion of penne alla vodka for my husband. Shockingly, the taste was reminiscent of vomit, which was a truly unfortunate surprise. It's truly disheartening to see such a decline in quality since our initial visit. This visit certainly left a bitter taste in our mouths, quite literally."

"Went to dinner with my wife. I'm a huge fan of Chicken Parm. What I'm not a fan of is giant chunks of tomatoes on my Chicken Parm. So I asked the waitress if the sauce was chunky if so I would have ordered a steak. She reassured me it was not. So that's what I ordered. I also ordered mozzarella block and when that came the sauce was chunky. So just wanting to make sure I asked again. For the 2nd time I was reassured it was not chunky. So it's time for my dinner to come. And guess what. I pulled off what seemed to be half of tomato???? Are you serious right now? The whole thing was more chunks then anything. Would not eat it. Really bummed me out cause I would have just ordered something else. I won't be going back for while and will let others know of my experience. Get it together stop flirting with other tables your tattoos ain't that great."

"I wouldn't wish on anybody these three wishes. Good service but lousy food. Stay away from the sandy muscles with watery garlic sauce. Don't come near the chewy, fatty, unedible prime rib. I'm not sure if the cook was always like this or he was just mad at the waitress. He maybe made sure the food going to her table was unacceptable. The kitchen staff definitely doesn't know anything about Italian food. I would not recommend this restaurant to my worst enemy."

"We were there last night. We had Deb as our waitress. She was great . Very friendly always made sure we had whatever we needed. Our food was delicious. That dill dressing is the best. Thank you for the great night."

"Had a very nice dinner here last night. Everything was delicious. I was pleasantly surprised. The service was excellent. Very friendly and knowledgeable about all the dishes and made some very good recommendations. I will definitely go back, hopefully soon!"