Witmer Automotive LLC,

1512 S George St, York, PA 17403, United States

"Witmer is one of the most honest auto shops I’ve been to. When the dealership almost failed my inspection, I took my jeep here to get a second opinion on the $700 motor mount that “needed” to be replaced. Brian and his team did a diagnostic and couldn’t figure out why the dealership even recommended that since it was fine! I saved $700 and also got my brakes replaced for a fraction of the dealership’s price. I’m forever grateful and the customer service was A+ as well. I was provided a shuttle to and from my home while they worked on the car and Brian took his time to explain everything to me and even provided tire quotes so I could prepare to replace those in the near future."

"I was scheduled for a diagnosis on a high idle on a 1996 Ford F150. I also asked for an estimate to replace a window motor, headlight, and tailpipe. I already had these components. On 10-25-23, Witmer had my truck from 8:00 am to 1:00 pm. and could not conclusively diagnosis the reason for the high idle. I was told they would send the estimate on the other repairs. They charged me $320.29 and did NOTHING. A week passed and I still did not have an estimate. When I called, Bryan told me that he would do the estimate and send it to me. Today is 1-5-24 and I have never received the estimate, no diagnosis, and no repairs. I took my truck to another shop in Baltimore. They diagnosed the issue, made the repair, gave me an estimate on the other repairs, and charged me $244.86. A scam? You tell me. I went there because of the reviews. Really? Bryan, I saw your response and you are full of it. I called you after a week. You NEVER called me! NEVER! You never left a message! You were supposed to email me. You never did. I was told that by the mechanic and by you. That is why you requested my email. You just now called me because you saw my review. That was the reason for your call. I did not answer because I was having supper. I have no desire to waste anymore time or money on Witmer!"

"Had to be at work at 12 so I dropped my car off at 10. The website said state inspections take 1 hour. 1.5 hours later I call multiple times to get a ETA but no one answered. I get there to be told it’s still not ready but they need to just print out stickers so it’ll be done soon. I let him know I have to be at work in 20 minutes…10 minutes later still not ready. After complaining again he wanted me to pay immediately without my car being in my possession. I literally had to leave in 30 seconds at this point. So it’s kinda wild that you still expected payment when I just said I had to leave right now and knowing I can’t pick my car up until the next day since they close during business hours at 5. If my boyfriend didn’t give me his car I don’t know what I would have done. I STILL ended up being 5 minutes late because of this incompetent business. Will NEVER go here again, so if you have things to do the day you book….dont come here because it took double the time it was suppose to"

"Great guys. Took my Vette in to get an alignment and some tires put on. Clinton did a thorough job making sure everything was in spec. Very friendly and professional. I'd recommend Witmer auto to anyone looking for an honest, local shop."

"I recently moved to York from Baltimore. I was looking for place to keep my Truck well maintained. I happened to drive by Witmer Auto and ck it out. Brian was extremly friendly and helpful. So far i have been for my State Inp , 2 oil changes a cold air intake , an upgrade exhaust and a set of JBA headers. Great service each time."