Amaya's Pizza & Italian Eatery 3681 Nottingham Way, Hamilton Township, NJ 08690

"Fantastic Pizza! We just tried a few of the gourmet pizza selections. The crust was perfectly done, the toppings were fresh, just delicious! I think you guys need to advertise more, I didn’t realize you were such a great a pizza restaurant!"

"Ate lunch at Amaya's yesterday with a friend. It was a fantastic experience. The owner/chef immediately greeted and seated us. Warm and DELCIOUS rolls were brought to the table. We ordered the cannelloni and eggplant rollatini. The meals included a very fresh garden salad. The portions were generous and the two sauces were fabulous. We were re-supplied with additional rolls without asking. The chef explained that he is inspired by his grandmother's recipes but makes them his own too. The chef was very warm, friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is named after his 6-month-old daughter. The menu is extensive including pizza, salads, sandwiches, pasta, meats and seafood. I highly recommend Amaya's. The prices are reasonable. We'll be back!!"

"What a wonderful place!! The pizza was delicious, and when I pre-ordered pizza for a birthday party, they were SO kind and helpful and even threw in a free pizza, which was amazing since it was for a pack of 12-year-old boys who demolished all 5 pizzas! AND to top it all off, they offered me paper plates to take for the boys. Anytime I’m back in the area they will absolutely get my business. They made our life a lot easier and the pizza was great. Thank you guys!!"

"DO NOT GO HERE. One of the worst restaurant experiences I’ve ever had. The bread was undercooked. We ordered the artichoke dip and it came out like a soup. The waiter has no understanding of the menu and brought two of the wrong ordered dishes to the table 45 minutes after we ordered. Instead of Cannelloni he brought a desert Cannoli. And totally forgot to put in one of the orders. Every pasta we ordered was mostly cheese with little pasta. I wanted to like this new restaurant but the experience was awful. Do not come here."

"Since moving to Hamilton this has to be the worst place I have gone to eat. First, we waited over an hour for a wrong salad, a slice of pizza and garlic knots. We only received them after we complained. The pizza was like 3 days old reheated pizza and garlic knots that had no taste what so ever. We asked for chicken Parmesan with vodka sauce and they brought regular chicken parm. When asked about the vodka sauce his response was I wrote the vodka sauce on the slip. Then when we go to eat the chicken we couldn’t even break it apart. When we did there was barely any chicken at all. It was mostly breadcrumbs (you get more chicken at wawas). We told the waiter this and they just took it away. No apology no resolution nothing. When asked for the check, he came and plopped it on the table with out saying anything at all. Very bad service and horrible food. Def will never go back there again. And I suggest everyone save their money by finding a better place to go."