Lenny's Pizzeria & Trattoria

"I’ve been coming here since 2003 - was 2 years old the first time. Lenny’s Pizza has been my and all my friends go-to slice for as long as I can remember. Same people still running the place after decades. Don’t know how this place could receive anything but 5 stars: providing an authentic & classy atmosphere for anyone dining in or stopping by and plenty of fresh options for anyone. Come for the pizza and you won’t regret it!"

"This is a wonderful local pizzeria and Italian restaurant. We usually go for the Margarita pizza, which is thin-crust with very fresh toppings. A simple place, clean and friendly, with upbeat decor. A little pricey but fun, with a wall covered with old photos."

"I ordered two mixed greens salads with a slice of veal because they didn’t have steak. I wish I didn’t get it to go because the veal tasted like paper and the mixed greens were never washed . The craziest part was when I asked if they put any bread in the bag, they told me that they never said they were going to include bread …For $57 seriously… a piece of bread … never in my life I experienced anything like.that.. Never again……."

"We ordered two pizzas to go from here and was told 20 minutes. I arrived at about the 19 minute mark and they were about to pull the pizzas out. The timing was sensational! Also the pizzas were piping hot and perfect! The margarita had a good amount of basil, cheese and sauce. I hope to come back here every time I am in the area!"

"2022 - This is a perfect example of why you visit Pizzerias on a yearly basis. Some Places continue to raise the bar, while others go in the other direction. Judging by some of the recent reviews as well, many people feel that the quality has gone down hill. I would agree as these were not the same slices that I had in 2021. The quality was not the same in my 2022 visit. Let me start with the Grandma Slice. The Sauce was way off. Tasted liked it looked, STALE. Now after just paying the bill, and paying $4.10 for 1 slice. Which has to be the most I have paid for a Speciality Grandma Slice ever. The Pepperoni was just a fill your belly Slice. Not sure what happend here, but I will.need to make some adjustments in Somerset County, NJ. 2021 -Margherita Slice was very Good. Good portion slices of Mozarella with a very good tasting sauce. The Crust was good, but could be great. That was the missing component for a 5. Just can't quite put my finger on it, but just needed something more with the crust to put it over the top. Service was average and the place was clean. I would go back."