Tony's Pizza

"Was super excited to try this place again. Had it multiple times in high school and was always happy. What a mistake. Ordered a white pizza well done and a Sicilian pizza. Pizzas were done fast and the parking lot is easy to access. Got home less then 4 minutes later and the white pizza was less done than I would even expect ordering the pizza normally. Very floppy and the base was moist and still very white. My girlfriend described the pizza as “cardboard”. No garlic or cheese taste and the crust wasn’t crusty at all. The Sicilian was not thin crust as described and tasted of less quality than a frozen pizza from the store. The sauce has no flavor and reminds me of a store brand pasta sauce. I’m definitely guessing they freeze their dough before preparing because the crust was airy and dry with no flavor. Very disappointed and will not be returning. I do remember this place being great in the past but after returning I find there is no real appeal. Pricing seems like a big complaint from many but I wouldn’t mind paying that for quality pizza. I was super hungry and only ate 2 slices/cuts because I was so surprised by the lack of quality. Very saddening but I do not suggest this pizza to anyone shopping in this area."

"From the outside of didn't look like much but the food speaks for itself! Pizza is perfect!"

"Loving these new(er) owners. I don't know why finding a good pizza place is so hard when you cross the PA boarder...We are very happy here! Just enjoyed a ginormous calzone. My son said his buffalo chicken pizza was the best ever...and the Caesar salad and garlic cheese bread were on point! So happy they deliver! Also find their food to be Much better than places that do not! Definitely check this place out if you haven't! Extra special thanks to the delivery man who went above and beyond apparently our ring isn't working and he actually found us on our back deck. A lot of places would have just left it on the front porch to get cold and leave us wondering why our food wasn't here. Super happy with this experience and our past few experiences. Thank you Tony's of Stockertown!"