Saylorsburg pizza

"The pizza here has been awesome ♡ I used to not care for the pizza here, I think they lightened up on the seasoning on the cheese pie ♡ Now it's very delicious!! We get pizza here about 2xs a month!"

"This place has good food. Unfortunately it seems to be one of these businesses that just don't give a hell, and will do whatever they want, when they want, regardless of posted hours. Which makes them super unreliable, and you never know what you're gonna get after a 30, 40, 50 minute drive over to them. I've shown up numerous times well before their official closing time, only to either find the doors locked and lights off, or the entire staff still inside, but the doors will be locked anyway. This past Sat, I showed up at 8:30pm, when their online hours say they're open to 9pm. Entire staff is still inside, but doors are locked. I knocked, guy comes to the door and tells me they're closing (everything was already cleaned up, which means they started closing WELL before 8:30pm, more like 8pm or earlier, at least a full hour before official closing). I ask him what time someone needs to show up to get food, he says "what does it say on the door?", I look and it says "8:30ish PM". I look at my clock, it's 8:33 PM. I have no words...It's a SATURDAY! If your hours are till 9pm, then you start closing at, or after, 9pm. NOT an hour before. After years of eating at this place, their service standards have slipped, little by little. Some of us don't want to eat dinner at 6-7pm, and I don't want to get hot food only for it to sit hours before I'm ready to eat. I'm sooo disappointed, I really liked this place. Where have the standards gone?"

"What can I say, decent pizza when you can get it. Open till 8? They Stop taking orders at 7pm! Trying for to place an order on a random Tuesday? The phone just rings and rings. More than half the time the pizza is cold when it gets to me despite being less than 3 miles from the store. I dunno, I guess they never stole my account number so they got that going for them. Literally the last resort."

"The pizza at Saylorsburg Pizza is absolutely phenomenal. The crust is the perfect thickness while also not being too doughy. The sauce is well flavored. The cheese is exactly what you want in a pizza cheese. FWIW, I've made pizza at multiple pizzerias in NJ. This place makes one of the best pizzas I've ever had."

"So yummy, pizza crust was absolutely perfect, sauce was delicious and cheese and pepperoni were not scimped on. We also ordered the "hot" wings which I thought were perfect but hubby would have liked a little saucier. Love that they deliver, and earlier than estimated."