Shelly Pie Pizza 912 Penn Avenue, Turtle Creek, PA 15145

"This has got to be the best pizza in Pittsburgh hands down! New York’s got nothin on Shelly Pie! Delicious, cheesy, perfect pizza right at your doorstep. Not to mention the other delicious menu items too and the great atmosphere when you dine in! Keep it up, Shelly Pie, no notes!"

"A great stop to grab a slice of pizza or two or three. The pies here are just that, thick cheesy, and a good crust. The size of this restaurant is decent with a large-ish parking lot to go with it. Thank goodness you don’t have to pay for parking. The staff here are friendly especially during those chaotic prime hours. I’ve had the food here a time or two but did dine in at least once and boy was there a party in there. To go has been good and dinging in is great as well, just get your damn pizza party on! This place is popular among the locals and so if you already know then you know. Everything I’ve gotten from here has been a delight so no complaints. Good, sweet tea. Gooey pizza, in my experience, piping hot, which is the best. The UHSHSHSHSAAHAHAH, is the best part when biting into something hot. There’s a bunch of food here that isn’t pizza as well, so there’s some options if you don’t want a tasty pie but a large menu indeed. Don’t come here if you’re on a diet. If you have then good, if you haven’t why not?"

"Delicious pizza! Fantastic waiter! My only ding is this-the charge for pop refills and NOT being told there is a charge. The wedding soup touches your soul and gives a nod to your Italian grandmother from the great beyond. Soft pretzels were ok. I loved the informational “how-to” on ordering pizza located on the menu!! Updated pizza review.. here goes: (These are all based on a scale of 1-5, with 1 being the worst and 5 the best.) Thickness of the dough: 5 Crust thickness: 3 a little too thick for my preference Toppings ratio: 3 they use a lot of pepperoni Crispiness: 5 (not crispy at all-which i like) Flavor:5 Price: 4 Size: 5 Crust overall: 3 Freshness:5"

"I hadn't gotten around to writing a review when my brother and I ordered here a few weeks ago but wanted to make sure to compliment the pizza here. We ordered both a Sicilian pie and a regular pepperoni pie and both exceeded expectations. The pepperoni was plentiful and both were delicious. I would not hesitate to order again next time I am in the area."

"Got 2 pizzas for take out. There were tons of toppings. Pizza was pretty good but some of the crust wasn't cooked. It was still doughy. Like raw dough bites. Not sure if this is the way it's supposed to be but we have to recook it back at our house. After we recooked it, it was real good. Boxes were soaked too."