Casa D' Amici 419 High Street, Morgantown, WV 26505

"Update 12/12/23 As you can see, I originally reviewed this restaurant years ago. We decided to try again and as usual, disappointing. When it's made good it is great, but it has gone down hill. Got our order and 1 pizza was completely burnt. The other was 1/2 burnt. On to the wings asked for extra saucy and got home with wings with NO SAUCE. As if that isn't bad enough, I called and spoke with the nice young man who took the order. He advised they would replace my order it would be on my account. Ok great. I then get a phone call from a Female who Q me and told me I could drive back 20 min to get a side of sauce. This exchange was ridiculous and the exact reason why I stopped spending my money at their establishment and the exact reason why I never will again. I thought I'll try again, but obviously, they do not care to steal your money and have gotten even worse with food quality and their non-existent customer service."

"The ambience in this place is like your Dad just got home from a long shift and is ready to yell at you, but he just so happens to make some god tier pizza. Golden slice, tenuous vibes. $3 pizza"

"Went on Saturday, 4/29/23, and ordered a make your own calzone and specifically requested to not have any seasonings on top and the cashier even confirmed my order correctly, however, when the calzone was done and handed it to me, it had seasoning on the top! The only excuse that was provided to me was that he told the chef but that “many of the folks who work here, don’t understand English”…he did offer to remake it but I could wait but wow, what a response…ended up just throwing it away and going to another local restaurant in town where my food was made correctly as ordered!!"

"I drive 2 hours and 35 minutes from Charles Town, WV just for taste this Pizza and the garlic knots. Is wonderful pizza. 100% recommended."