Kitty Murtagh's 4 West Creek Road, Nantucket, MA 02554

"Great, unassuming Irish pub/restaurant on this fabulous island! Great traditional pub fare and other delicious food, Irish beer on tap, billiards and soccer on all the televisions makes for an easy, family friendly visit"

"Went on a weekend evening in late fall and it was busy but there were definitely still a few open tables. We ordered drinks and they came out quickly, but the food was a different story. Part of the group got there 15 minutes before I did and they ordered appetizers while they waited. When I preferred my drink I also put in an appetizer. After a substantial wait and several apologies from the waiter, the first 2 appetizers came out followed shortly by my appetizer followed shortly by the main dishes. If the 6 main dishes ordered, 2 were incorrect and 1 (steak frittes) were so overcooked they were entirely black and crunchy. By the time we paid it had been nearly 3 hours that we were there in total, most of which was spent between ordering and receiving the food. The food that was correct was pretty good, but service was slow at best and half of the meals were incorrect or cooked to the point it was inedible. Maybe we caught them on a bad night, I can’t be the judge of that, but this was my experience."

"We had a blast at Kitty's! We stopped for a quick bite that turned out to be one of our favorite meals during our stay, and we couldn't stop talking about how good everything was for the rest of the trip. Our server was so attentive and good-humored, he made our day. Thanks Kitty's!!"

"Parking a little hard very busy establishment which says the food is good outside bar and inside bar very authentic German cuisine had the New England clam chowder was excellent also had a fried chicken sandwich. Along with the Caesar salad bartender was very accommodating you can tell that this establishment has roots it's been there for a while and they have made a lot of great relationships that's a sign of a good restaurant check it out!"

"$5.00 Burger night every Tuesday, can't beat that deal. Don't want a beef burger same thing goes for a chicken patty burger. $5.00 Burger Tuesdays are on hold but the masks are great."