Mac's Fish House Provincetown 85 Shank Painter Road, Provincetown, MA 02657

"Excellent quality and wide-ranging choice of seafood at this car-accessible location (ample free parking). Being a bit removed from the old center and close to the limited access Rt 6, this location attracts customers from other locations on the Cape as well as day trippers to PTown. We had an 8:15 pm reservation. For most of the dinner we were inundated with loud, raucous noise from a party of at least 20 mature adults/seniors. Being seniors ourselves, my husband and I are neither antisocial nor party-poopers but we do enjoy having a quiet conversation during dinner. My rating of two stars on ‘atmosphere’ reflects ambiance more akin to Madison Square Garden or Yankee Stadium ( go Bombers!) rather than a restaurant. This may not be representative of most diners’ experience here, but being a large location, the seating host could have offered a choice of seating with one option being farther away from the noisy party. That’s a shame because the kitchen prepared first class seafood, and our waiter was friendly and mostly customer focused. There were a few delays in serving. I had a non-gringo spicy swordfish with green curry and rice. Outstanding! My husband had salmon. Very fresh, cooked to perfection and unrestrained spicing. Pricing was fair given the high quality of the fish. There is also a fish market at the same location open during the day. All in all, I recommend that this restaurant, but don’t be shy about wearing your favorite team cap! (It’s not a romantic restaurant)"

"I had a fantastic dining experience at Mac's Fish House in Provincetown! The service was incredibly friendly and welcoming, making us feel right at home. The highlight of the meal was undoubtedly the fresh seafood. The Oysters, Clams, Mussels, and Lobster were all impeccably fresh and delicious, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality. I was pleasantly surprised by the sushi offerings, which were equally impressive. The Korean chicken sandwich was a delightful departure from traditional seafood, and its flavors were outstanding. While the dessert options were limited, the flourless chocolate cake was a sweet note to end the meal on. Overall, Mac's Fish House offers a diverse and satisfying seafood experience with exceptional service, making it a must-visit in Provincetown."

"We had dinner here on a Friday night. The restaurant was fairly busy. We were seated with our reservations within 10 minutes. We had already decided that we would have sushi tonight and everyone ordered cocktails, sushi roll and soup. The craft cocktails were good. We tried the miso soup and clam chowder. The flavors were good but I’ll have to admit I like my chowder thicker yet I also understand traditional thin as well. The miso was good too. The sushi rolls were very slow coming out of the kitchen and our server was also slow on keeping our beverages topped off. Bar service seemed slow as well. All in all the restaurant was clean and well kept but the sushi rolls were just average. If we go back I won’t be having the sushi. They also have a fresh fish market which has excellent fresh seafood. UrbanCowgill Aug 2023"

"This place wowed us. I came thinking I would try a lobster roll since I’d never had one but the menu was so extensive and exciting I didn’t bother with the lobster. I couldn’t decide between 4 options so I let our really great waiter help me pick. My Spicy Ahi Tuna dinner was amazing and so was my daughters build your own fish tacos. Expensive but worth it in my opinion. My mother in law did not appreciate their culinary take on clam chowder but I think that’s because she was looking for a classic, thick and creamy chowder. This place is taking creative license with their dishes so don’t expect classic Americana food. It has a more Asian twist."

"You won’t go wrong with any seafood seen on the menu… try the happy hour after 3 PM and you get oysters at half the price… yes It’s a BIG DEAL..! Love this place"