Three Sisters

"We stopped there this week for a quick bite and the sandwiches were so delicious. I loved the names of all of them too! What I most appreciated though was the service…my toddler son was having a hard time while we were there and one of the workers was so sweet to offer him a tour of their kitchen and a chocolate chip cookie. I appreciated the kindness and understanding they showed us, thank you!!"

"Casual sandwich and salad stand with a small but appropriate menu. Outdoor (only) seating is available. Bike rack is present. Service is quick. Recommended."

"We’ve always gone to Three Sisters for lunch, they have the best sandwiches and chocolate chip cookies on then island. Tonight we went for dinner for the first time and oh my gosh this is an absolute must! Their crostini sandwiches are to die for! Fresh ingredients, cooked to perfection, large portions for sharing, wonderful staff, live music, and a beautiful outdoor ambience under the string lights. You will not be able to find a more delicious and relaxing dinner on the island. 100/10 recommend. Honestly the best dinner we have had on the island and we can not wait to go back!"

"Sandwiches made with fresh everything! Watched them slice the meat in the back, veggies were crisp, sauces were original and perfectly applied. Prices reasonable for the island, quick food arrival even though busy. Very amiable and fun staff. Lots of outdoor seating options (no indoor). Fun casual vibe. Seems like they would keep well if you wanted to take to the beach."

"Cute, clean cottage like shop for a nice lunch. Outdoor eating. Cash only. Menu is full of fresh, delicious sandwiches, big homemade cookies and desserts. Great find and our new favorite!"