Rehoboth Baking Co

"First time trying the New location for Rehoboth Baking Co. Previous experience was at the old location and it did not go as well. I ordered ahead online this time and picked it up at 4pm. Very happy to see that it was ready to go when I got there. Went with a New Haven style Meat sweats without the meatball and an order of their garlic wings. The pizza was very good overall. A little light on toppings, a little greasy, not too bad. Wings were well seasoned. Not as garlicky as I hoped for. Still worth a try. Pizza gets a 7.8/10."

"If you like a nice thick crust, the Detroit is your pie. We have been ordering from here and love their fresh made pies. The bakery items will make your mouth water. The fresh made breads, desserts and cookies....the cookies!!! So glad this place is within walking distance. Very friendly staff and cute dining area."

"Lovely modern-rustic-styled restaurant that has a great variety of food. We got pasta, wings, and a couple styles of both pizza and salad. Everything we had was delicious and exceeded our expectations. They also have a good selection of alcoholic and soft drinks as well as a dozen-or-so options for those with a sweet tooth."

"I was a fan when it was just based out of the country store. I’m an even bigger fan now that they’ve opened the restaurant. Firstly, their pizza is divine. You can get 3 types of crust- bar pizza, New Haven, and Detroit. Each are wonderful and homemade. I also love the red sauce they make which can make or break a pizza; theirs is outstanding. Their sandwiches all come on their homemade bread & again, just delicious. If you have a sweet tooth, I highly recommend their desserts. My favorite is their bread pudding. There is always a steady stream of customers and I can see why. It’s a great place. Everyone who works there is very friendly!"