Mickys Pizza

"Very very good pizza with quality ingredients. Crispy and soft crust, no flop. Very charming with good mom n pop ambiance. Only downside was that it was very cold out and we went to dine in and the doors were WIDE open. They said we couldn’t close them so the entire dine-in area was freezing cold. Definitely took away from the experience. Pizza should be eaten fresh out of the oven."

"The owner/manager was very accommodating and answered all my questions in a genuine and helpful way. Pizza by the slice is a great option for solo travelers and is a nice surprise to discover it was available. The store has charm and character. I particularly liked how well lit it was it felt very Christmas like."

"Service is as amazing as their pizza. Truly authentic NY style pizza. One of their employees Ethan was awesome. Also got to meet Karen the owner and she was so sweet. Gotta love my long islanders!!"

"Updated: after posting my initial experience I connected with the restaurant and they went above and beyond to rectify what was seemingly an honest mishap with the recipe. Customer service was top notch and on 2nd go around the pizza was very good! Would be back again to support this establishment!!! Thanks Mickys! Initial review: Ordered 2 pizzas for takeout, got home and at first bite realized they were SO SALTY they were actually inedible So disappointed as this got great reviews and the pizza looked great on presentation"

"Best oven cooked pizza in NK. Period. The red sauce, the quality of dough, the owner’s default cook specificity and crust are all A+. We did half plain and half pepperoni. We also got the garlic knots that were incredible. Looks like this is our new pizza place!"