Goodfella's New York Italian Deli

"First time there I had the Roast Pork with Broccoli Rabe and Provalone Hoagie. One of the best hoagies I've had in awhile."

"THE best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had! I will admit I was a bit bummed when she said they only had brioche buns and not Kaiser rolls but whoa, so delicious. I thought New York did them best, but this spot is top notch. Friendly staff too. Highly recommend!"

"I was looking for something to different to eat in the area. I jumped online and started searching for places and landed on this spot. I took a look at their menu and decided this was the place to try. I decided to go with the Rowan fat sandwich and I was delighted. Sorry I didn't take a picture this time but it is a good sized sandwich and you all know how important quantity is to me as the price of everything is going up. The staff were very friendly and patient with me as I was making my final decision. Service is another important aspect to me where food is concerned. I highly recommend this place. Going to go back and try some other things but I can promise you the hot sandwiches are on point."

"As someone who worked in an authentic Italian-American deli for years in my youth, I have pretty high standards for not only the food but also the cleanliness and friendliness of a place. Goodfella's gets five stars from me. I can't imagine that my family and I live within minutes of this deli, but we have only just now discovered them! Our first visit was in late September of 2023, and in under two months, we've gotten takeout from them five times! I waited to write this review just to be sure we didn't have a fantastic fluke the first time, but by five visits, having now sampled much of their menu - pastrami, corned beef, hot roast beef, chicken cutlets, meatballs, WINGS, and more - I can honestly say we haven't had one "bad" thing yet! The sandwiches are REAL DEAL and packed with meat and flavor. Don't sleep on the wings, either. As someone who used to drive almost an hour to get "the best" wings in SJ, I am thrilled because I won't have to anymore. Goodfella's wings are THAT good! They come naked, and we chose the hot and honey sauce on the side. Absolutely mouthwatering! Same with the roast beef. I won't have to cross the bridge to go to Nick's anymore, unless I'm feeling nostalgic, because they roast their beef and pork for five hours and it's absolutely melt in your mouth delicious. Besides having a varied menu, they also carry a nice selection of hard to find drinks. My husband rarely comes back without bringing me a Peace Tea, Vanilla Cream, or Black Cherry soda. The ladies who answer the phone are great, too. They take our sometimes complicated orders with a pleasant attitude, and they've never made a mistake! We really have found a gem with Goodfella's!!"

"I'll be honest. I didn't know this place existed until I did a search for "Italian roast beef sandwich". This past week I had 4 sandwiches here 4 days in row. All excellent. The hot roast beef. The one with the eggplant and chicken. The corned beef special and reuben. I think I will try a different sandwich every time I'm here."