Cafe Sitaly 1710 Naamans Road, Wilmington, DE 19810

"Usually order from here on a regular basis. Ordered a pizza the other night. Husband and I both had severe stomach pain right after. Ended up having food poisoning all night. Also when I called and ordered I had to ask for the total, didn't ask for my name or phone number which I found strange. Took an hour to show up."

"Snow night and this place was open cozy and warm and the food was delicious the lasagna was tasty and the chicken parm was good"

"This is my second negative experience with service at Cafe Sitaly. First let me say, I am a server myself and have worked from catering, to VIP table service, to fast-paced restaurant service, to casual dining. Upon entering there were 8 employees from the floor to the kitchen, with no one seating, hosting, or directing people crowded by the door. People were waiting for tables, waiting to pay for takeout, and waiting for pickup. Two young adults in charge of this station were on their phones or plating garlic knots and neglecting the growing line of people in the door. Once I was seated, the average time between seating and ordering a beverage was 10-12 minutes. Some people waited 22 minutes just to place drinks and an appetizer. When I did place a drink and app, my app did not come out for an additional 27 minutes. We are now 39 minutes into dinner service and the app was asked to be brought out by the server 5 times, which the kitchen “forgot” and “blamed it on her”. Mind you, this young waitress is who I had last time, and has no direction, table management, or aid from her coworkers. So I cannot blame her. There are 2 people cleaning tables and one person serving 8 tables. Eight. The bussers reset but do not do the least to offer water and bread. The lead waitress also runs food and her counterparts disappear into the kitchen to wait for food or go on their phones (visible to the rest of the restaurant). Overall the food was fantastic but due to lack of service orderliness I will not return. I felt extremely bad for the two women next to me who were scolded for asking for a lemon and straws and their order was partially incorrect, as well as the two couples who sat after me who waited 12-17 minutes to place a drink order for water. Followed by 7+ minute periods with no one on the floor. I enjoy the food but the service and kitchen staff do not have direction and the superfluous staff standing around watching one server drown is uncalled for. Not to mention she needs to shadow someone to become efficient in providing quality service as a baseline."

"First time coming here, and the experience was solid. The restaurant is a small well-decorated eatery with several booths for dine-in. Our server was friendly, and our food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. The bread given, for starters, was hot and soft. I could have eaten the whole basket, but I had to share. The fried calamari was soft, tender, and not chewy at all. I was expecting the sauce for Chicken Alfredo to be a little thicker, but that could be their style. The chicken was seasoned nicely, though. The personal Italian Stromboli was sizeable and more than enough for one person. I asked a couple as they were leaving, and the Grandmom Pizza came with a good recommendation. They were right! The crust was good, and the sauce tasted nice and fresh, with good cheese and plenty of fresh basil. The staff was friendly, and all wished us good evening as we left. Overall we had a decent experience. I would dine here again."

"I have to say, this is top notch Italian food. The place is small but the flavor here is amazing and you really feel like family. I love the atmosphere and you can take food to go. Even though you most likely will have to wait a bit for a table or booth, it’s 100% worth it because the food is delicious. There is a family restroom and a single person men’s room and they are very clean. I highly recommend this place if you are looking for quality Italian cuisine!"