The Hidden Gem Cafe 275 Broadhollow Road, Melville, NY 11747

"This is SO good!! Also FYI they’re in the basement of the bank building. These prices are incredible for the quality of food you’re getting. Less than $5 for a huge egg sandwich?! Amazing! Can’t recommend enough. Will be back for sure. Edit: tried to leave a second 5 star review but can only edit this one. Consistently great food. Best egg sandwich in the area - by far!"

"I used the Hidden Gem cafe to cater my backyard wedding in 2020 and am going back to have them cater my daughter’s first birthday party. The food is delicious & the cakes they make are absolutely incredible. They really are a hidden gem and my family is going to continue to use them for all of our catering needs."

"Awesome food and staff. Catering always arrived on time and ready to serve with minimal set up required. They even included utensils for serving and extra dressings. The in person location is also worth the trip to go to if you have time. Always greeted with a smile and the food does NOT disappoint. Super clean and friendly. Try the hidden parmwich!!!!"

"I recently visited The Hidden Gem Cafe, and it truly lives up to its name. This cafe is an absolute gem that offers an exceptional menu. The standout item on their menu is "The Captain" sandwich, which surpassed all expectations. Additionally, their meal preps are outstanding—convenient, nutritious, and bursting with flavor. The atmosphere at The Hidden Gem Cafe is cozy and inviting, complemented by attentive and friendly staff. They demonstrate a genuine passion for their craft. The Hidden Gem Cafe is a must-visit for anyone seeking some amazing food. Whether you're indulging in "The Captain" sandwich or enjoying their delicious and convenient meal preps, every aspect of my visit was amazing. Don't miss out on this hidden gem. I forgot to take a picture of The Captain but here is another delicious one sandwhich i had "The Crispy Pickle""

"I’ve been meaning to write this review since Cassidy and Amanda catered my daughter’s graduation party on Saturday. We had such a pleasant experience and I can’t say enough about how fresh and delicious the food was. We received such favorable feedback from all our guests too! The star of the evening had to be the grazing table! It was a work of art and Cassidy set it up to perfection. Thank you Hidden Gem for an A+ experience!"