The Skyline Restaurant McLeod Street, Edinburgh EH11 2NL

"We celebrated our son's 33rd birthday in the Skyline restaurant yesterday. He lives in Budapest and we were looking for something a bit special and different to go. What an excellent choice. Very good food, nicely presented by lovely staff who couldn't do enough for us. What a pleasure. Well done Hearts - that's a winning formula."

"Excellent service and good value for money. Very disappointed that turkey was off the menu (kind of standard for a Christmas meal). I had fish instead, which was a bit greasy. Others in my group enjoyed their mains and all starters were good."

"Fantastic food and experience. Excellent views of the castle and surrounding areas. Booked a table for 8 people and were promptly seated after arriving. Had an unusual prawns and seafood on crumpet starter that was exceptional. Burger for main followed by tiramisu which were both tremendous. This would be a fantastic place for new years eve to watch the castle fireworks."

"Excellent lunch, staff were absolutely superb: reserved yet extremely attentive and ultra polite. Food was beautifully presented, served nice and hot, and tasted delicious. Best dining experience in a very long time. Restaurant is extremely clean, with a very relaxed atmosphere. Can’t wait to go back."

"A pleasant venue with very attentive and efficient staff. Cannot fault the service at all. The standard of food varied between the dishes - for example, the chicken roulade was very dry whereas the lamb was tender and delicious. They have a great cocktail menu and wine list, and the prices overall (for both food and drink) are quite fair & reasonable. The view is a bit of a disappointment for a venue called "Skyline" - in the evening you can't see anything at all (no perspective over the city lights or anything like that), and during the day all you see are the tops of tenement buildings. I couldn't see any other city landmarks, but that may have been partly due to the location of our table. I would return here in future but probably only with a large group, as the resturant seems particularly well set-up for bigger tables and larger groups of people."