Terrace Bagelry & Deli 876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY 11752

"8/16/24. Well came here after not coming since my last review. Was excited as I noticed it’s a new owner (the last guy was horrible). It was Busy but my order was taken quickly. I asked for an egg white omlette with bacon, cheese, and spinach mixed in. I specifically said mixed in. I also asked for rye toast. Service was ok- not overly friendly- but that was fine. I waited about 10-15 minutes for my order. I got home and what I was served can not be considered an omelette. The egg whites were folded and then the spinach on top with the cheese on top of that. The bacon? Thrown on top of all that. The toast- cinnamon raisin. I got in my car and asked for a refund. The guy who must be the new owner apologized but didn’t really seem sorry. I will again never come here and continue to go to Harry’s on the other end of town Came here at 6:15 on 3/24 and tried to order an egg sandwich. I was told “griddle doesn’t work” and that’s it. No apology or offer to do anything else. Left empty handed and disappointed and went to another place"

"Aside from the fact that majority of the staff is rude Doesn’t really bother me because I can hold my own and no one can beat me If given the opportunity. Every single time I order my bacon egg and cheese with salt and pepper no ketchup it always comes with ketchup. I’m not understanding why that is. I’m not sure if they’re illiterate. I’m not sure if they’re doing it spitefully I’m not sure if it’s just auto pilot and they automatically add ketchup. But this is one too many times. I literally say it slowly for them each time loud and clear can I have a bacon egg and cheese On A plain bagel One fried egg, salt, and pepper, and please no ketchup no ketchup please. Every time I drive and I get ready to eat my sandwich there’s ketchup. The thing that sucks is that they actually make good Breakfast sandwiches when they do it correctly and I live minutes away. I just ordered a sandwich and left at 9:50 this morning got home and found ketchup on my sandwich not alittle bit ALOT. Unfortunately this will be my last time and I will continue to spread this to everyone I know. oh and out of all the breakfast places, I know they are most expensive and are portioned with more bacon this place only puts like 1-2 slices of bacon"

"Seems like they tried to make up for the lack of bacon with globs of cheese...to pay almost $9 and not feel full, it's not worth it. Other places charge $7 for a better portioned bacon egg and cheese sandwich."

"Stopped in around 130 to get tuna on a bagel. The place was empty so I was able to order quickly. The bagel was a bit stale but it was late in the day for these guys as they close at 3. The tuna was good and so was the service. They were not very friendly but they were professional. They have a good selection of bagels and toppings. There are a few seats, so eating in would not be an issue here. The place is plain, but it's a bagel store. The restaurant is clean, although I did not check the bathrooms. Prices are average for a bagel store. If you are in the area and want a bagel, this is a good choice. This place is in a small shopping center so parking is not a problem."

"Really great deli/ bagel shop. The food is really good and the place is clean and well appointed. The people working behind the counter were hilarious when I first walked in here and had me laughing the whole time. Glad I tried it! Only downside is that it's a bit hard to find..."