The Pizzeria of Bayport

"We come for the gluten-free pizza and dairy free cheese!! The pizza is so delicious! First time in 15 years, I've had gluten-free pizza that tastes like regular pizza!!! Thank you!!!"

"Had dinner with my daughter and grandkids. It was packed. All the tables were occupied and take out didn't stop. This establishment is well run. Orders were filled quickly and most importantly, the food is delicious!!!!"

"(This is an edited review) Wow. My original review was pure dissatisfaction. The pizza was a 2/5 and I was being generous in that review because the atmosphere was nice and so were the people. The owner assured me that this was a one-off and that they have a high standard of pizza and made it right with me after my lack-luster purchase. I figured let me try another type in case the pepperoni just isn’t good at this place. I said I would go back and try it again and I did. I tried something sort of different— half pep and half Buffalo chicken. What a difference! I mean, this pizza is by far some of the best I’ve had on Long Island! I expected it to be better, but not to this extent! I actually feel bad for my original review now. So glad I gave them another shot! 5 stars all around! And to the owner: Hats off to you and your team, sir! Well done! That’s how to run a business! Highly, highly recommend!"

"“YOU DESERVE GREAT PIZZA” indeed you do. And you will definitely get greatness in this pizzeria. You can’t go wrong with ANY of their slices. Great job The Pizzeria."

"In Long Island from Pittsburgh doing production work for a comedy show. Was craving some real NY style pizza but I'm not in the city. Holy heck is this place AMAZING. Their pepperoni is the best I've ever tasted, crust is perfect, excellent cheese and sauce. To top it off, the manager at the Bayport location called me to let me know it's coming Doordash but I ordered on their website - He said the dasher may not speak English, may not see my instructions for delivery so they made sure they wrote it down for him. Awesome, awesome place! Thanks!"