Middle Island Pizza 586 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

"Nice variety of specialty slices and different kinds of rolls. Super convenient at the top of the hill right next to Walmart. I would rate it above slightly above average for the regular slice and above average for the specialty slices. Nothing to change complain about."

"While the food here is good, the overall experience is marred by several significant issues. The staff is often abusive, and the hygiene standards are questionable. Reports from former employees highlight misconduct among the staff and impractical working conditions without adequate compensation. It's a shame because good food deserves to be enjoyed in a welcoming and sanitary environment (stop scratching your back with the spatula, you know who you are, and clean your pizza ovens). Unfortunately, until these issues are addressed, it's hard to recommend dining here."

"Pizza was great and the garlic knots are amazing. Their Italian sausage is so good. The crust could be a little less done, but that's a personal preference. I definitely recommend this place and will be back if I'm ever in the area."

"Fantastic pizza, crust is awesome and the toppings are top tier. Friendly staff and great prices, will be going back."

"Worst experience ever, I recomend going anywhere else. If I could I would give them -3stars for customer service. I am a disabled v.a veteran and I am willing to pay extra for good friendly service. If you want that go else where. My father ordered my a chicken parm dinner and they forgot to give him the pasta, also I went to get my own order i walked. I ordered 2 orders of garlic knots they didn't have a lid on either. On my double order of sausage and peppers they would have used two containers instead of over filling one. It was a mess the lid was melted and as a result it leaked out and got all over the bag and my shorts. They never apologized for the forgetting of the pasta. I did not feel like a valued customer. I didn't want a free meal, I just wanted to let them know I was not happy. Now I will no longer do business with these people."