Ye Olde Pizza Shoppe

"My party and I showed up for a trivia night. It was already so packed and they still happily accommodated our group. The service and food were both awesome despite the amount of people. Our whole group had a blast! Would 100% come back."

"UPDATE: I was contacted by management and given apology and 1 free pizza. I have changed my rating from 1 star only cause negative stars are not possible to 2 honest stars. I will say once we recooked the pizza in our oven it was way better and not doughy. Not crunchy but better. I am willing to rereview after we try free pizza. I hope they take the time to work with people cooking the pizzas as they said they were going to do. ORIGINAL POST: So was excited to try. The yops was good. Crust flavor not my fav but good pizza. However the Problem was the other pizza the Hawaiian. I like thin crust and usually it doesn't matter if there's pineapple on the crest or not. The thin if cooked right will be crispy.. However apparently at this store that is not the case. When I got the pizza and it was super soggy. I called in and talked to the supervisor who informed me that because we put a pineapple pizza on a thin crust the juice would go to the bottom and therefore be soggy and there's nothing they could do about it. Mind you there was burn edges and doughy center on the underside of the pizza. She was not very polite and kept telling me that the problem with the pizza was because the way I ordered it and not because the way they cooked it. I have had thin crust at multiple places with pineapple and veggies and never been given such rude excuses by the supervisor before. Will not go back. Do not advise. Also only seasonings on pizza seem to be black paper and oregano."

"This is hands down the best quality pizza in the area. The menu has all of the classics, as well as a few specialty pizzas that you'll definitely be making return trips to try. Not to mention the great selection of appetizers and pastas, there's something for everyone. The atmosphere is incredibly inviting, and with regular trivia and singo nights (a must experience twist on traditional Bingo) there is always a reason to visit. They also have introduced delivery! All of the details can be found on their easy to use website."

"Ye Olde Pizza Shoppe, Well, I have been wanting to try this place for some time. First time I stopped in by the time someone came out, I couldn't wait any longer to have lunch. That was a while ago finally seen they have a lunch buffet and thought that's great it will be fast. When I walked in, I didn't see a menu and wasn't sure where to go. Door opens to a pick-up spot, and the register is to the right, just in a side room where the buffet pizza was as well. The inside was pretty cool with the ammunition and ordinance box wood on the walls. This lower area is rather small with the tables to sit at in another room from the buffet crossing the main entry door. I could see a potential issue if it were to get busy. Ok, the pizza, this is a hard one. I was starving and craving pizza. I came in towards the end of the buffet time, so I kinda of get it. The pizza was so dry and hard with a cracker style thin crust that was so dry it was crazy. Even the toppings were dry. I was debating on whether to try it or not. But I only had a short time for break, so I tried. So so dry! After I paid, I was told they would have a fresh pizza out in a few minutes it took about 12 to 15 minutes, not too bad on time, really, but it was obvious they really didn't plan on having anyone show up for the time remaining of the buffet that ends at 3. Turns out the fresh pizza was better mainly because the cheese was more melted, but the crust was just as dry. I know some people like the cracker style crust. I guess I'm not a fan. Honestly, the biggest problem I had was after I left and grabbed a few more drinks was the aftertaste, and the only time I get that way is with canned sauce. Like I said, I kind of get it. it's a buffet, and at the end of the time, Frame. It does seem like a lot of things are changing. There is a sign that says they will be closed on Tuesday. I think to put more stuff in there or upstairs, but I'm not sure. And of course, this could have just been a one-off bad day I have seen good reviews if I come back for a second chance, not the buffet, definitely but something else and it's good I will update this review but it might be awhile. Sorry Ye Old Pizza Shoppe I think the pizza just sat out too long. Hope it's better next time."