Leah's Italian Restaurant

"Our server was very nice and friendly. I'm pretty sure they had Phil Collins' greatest hits playing in the dining room, with car racing on the tv. I'm sure someone enjoyed it, but it wasn't what i expected at an Italian restaurant. Seemed like "the" place to bring elderly folks. The minestrone soup is literally canned soup that they "doctor up". Fettuccine alfredo was watered down, utterly bland and lacking in flavor, creaminess, and body. Someone raved about their garlic bread, but i don't know why. I found it to be somehow simultaneously greasy & dry. Overall, the entire experience was quite disappointing."

"Went there with family. Had the lasagna which was really bad. So much cheese, that is all I tasted. Sauce was thin as water with no taste. We also tried the spaghetti which my niece hated, red colored water as sauce, no taste. My sister had the pizza and said it was not to bad but would not go back. Service was aweful. Not sure how this place got such good reviews."

"Awful! Anyone that gives this food a star rating above 1 has never had real Italian food. Sauce that taste like it was from a jar, "meat" lasagna was under 1" high, hardly any meat, the meat that I did see was ground chuck, too much mozzarella cheese that it was chewy. Ravioli that looked and tasted like frozen. Spaghetti with sausage was diced in the sauce and not a link on the side. Corelle dishes that were mismatched and were from the 80's. Server was friendly and attentive."

"The staff at Leah's is so friendly. My parents went here for dinner every Saturday night for years. I went there last night with my brother and sister-in-law and head a wonderful dinner. Whatever you order, getting a side of their garlic bread is a must. It's to die for. I had the eggplant Parmesan which was one of the best I've had. My brother had the spinach lasagna, which was also amazing and my sister-in-law had the chicken linguine, one of her favorites. The bottle of wine was also perfect."

"Please let me explain my total review. First is price. It's on a 14" pizza and the price was $17.87 for a two topping pizza. Crossroads in Franklin 5 min from there is $18 for a 16" pizza and it's way better. Now when eating this pizza it tastes very much like Jack's frozen pizza but it's better. But better than Jack's which can cost $3 is not comparable. I'm Italian tho and I prefer Italian tasting pizza. Scotty's in West Allis is the best. I've heard the Lasagna is delicious here and I will definitely give it a try. But the pizza tastes slightly better than frozen and it costs $17?? For a 14"? Do not suggest. At Scotty's with "The Great Scott" special you can get two 16" pizzas for $31. And it's the best in the city."