Amica Mutual Insurance Company

"I've been a loyal Amica customer for over 10 years for all my insurance needs. Never a claim or any issue on my insurance. Then this year for no reason they increased my auto insurance by 40% (Near the max allowed by CA regulators. Surprised they would be so greedy with their loyal customers). The only good thing is that Amica at least gave me 2 months notice so that I could shop around and find out that I could get even better coverage at a lower price than even my last year rates."

"Out of blue they increased my car insurance rates for nissan versa from $1300 to $1800 for 6 month. Because it is California, and because of "global warming". Got insurance from gaico for $900 with better coverage,"

"I added my husband to my policy. He got in a single accident. Amica sent me a letter 3 weeks before my renewal date that they will not be renewing my insurance due to my husband's one accident. They said I could keep my coverage and exclude him, but my existing policy would cancel and I'd have to start a new one which was higher and they wanted half down. I asked if they could just exclude my husband after he gets his own policy this way I could keep my policy without all the extra fees. He told me in California that's not allowed. Never heard of this. Also said that half down is a California thing. Again, never heard of that. Horrible company."

"California homeowner's insurance - a two-headed dragon of California Fair Plan (CFP) forms and separate fire/personal property policies. I was ready to give up and concede into spending double, until Amica appeared like a knight in shining armor. One simple policy, friendly experts like Stephanie B, and thousands saved? No more fire-breathing paperwork here. Amica, you're the magic spell I needed."

"I was rear ended by an Amica member. My car was no longer drivable. The agent never even reached out. I called in repeatedly asking for things to be done and it was pulling teeth. At one point she tried to tell me that they were rescinding my rental even though my car wasn’t fixed. Not drivable. The body shop she picked couldn’t work on my car. I had to call around body shops to find someone to fix it and then she suddenly changed her mind and I got to keep the rental. They did not reimburse my parking tickets for my car being on the road unfixed until it was able to be towed by them (weeks). Very difficult and unfortunate experience. I have been rear ended before and the experience with the other insurance company was nothing like this"